August 27, 2005 · Posted in: General

Messing with the party list

AS a significant political and electoral reform measure, Republic Act 7491 set up the mechanism of the party-list system to ensure proportional representation in the election of representatives to the House of Representatives, allowing underrepresented and marginalized sectors to vie for 20 percent of seats in the legislature.

Ten years since its enactment, the spirit of the Party-List System Act of 1995 has yet to be fully realized as most Filipinos remain uninformed about the party-list process, no thanks to a virtually non-existent voter education program of the Commission on Elections. Worse, as the "Hello Garci" tapes reveal, the party-list system apparently has been hijacked to serve the politics of patronage and spoils.

This week’s PCIJ site feature from the i Report special issue, Messing with the Party List, shows that Malacañang-favored party-list groups got more than a little help from the Comelec fraud squad in the 2004 elections. In the taped conversations involving Virgilio Garcillano, the former poll commissioner was heard in several instances discussing the chances of at least five party-list groups publicly endorsed by Pres. Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo that were vying for seats in Congress:

  • Veterans’ Freedom Party (VFP)
  • Ang Laban ng Indiginong Filipino (ALIF)
  • Alliance for Nationalism and Democracy (ANAD)
  • Samahan ng mga Mangangalakal sa Ikauunlad ng Lokal na Ekonomiya (SMILE)
  • Trade Union Congress Party (TUCP)

Two of these groups already have representatives seating in the House: Ernesto Guidaya of VFP and Acmad Tomawis of ALIF. The Comelec is also expected to proclaim ANAD as another winner and make its first nominee, ex-communist-turned vigilante Jun Alcover, a congressman.

Guidaya is a retired military man who once headed the Philippine Veterans’ Affairs Office (PVAO), an agency under the Armed Forces of the Philippines. Tomawis, whose assumption as congressman is being questioned by another party-list group, Partido Manggagawa (PM), is said to be a "big businessman engaged in overseas trucking, particularly trucking services in Iraq."

Recently, Tomawis’s brother, Sultan Yahya, was appointed by Pres. Arroyo as executive director of the Office for Muslim Affairs (OMA), a move that was seen as a concession in order for the party-list representative not to sign the impeachment complaint against the president.

The said party-list groups benefitted from questionable poll results in the provinces of the Autonomous Region of Muslim Mindanao (ARMM), including the unknown Visayas Farmers Party or Agrifil which topped the elections in Basilan with 90,000 votes. With "no clear constituency" in ARMM, its base being the Western Visayas province of Aklan, Capiz, Guimaras and Iloilo where it got only 11,464 votes,  Agrifil’s win has been contested by the party-list group Anak Mindanao (AMIN).

Read the report at pcij.org

64 Responses to Messing with the party list

Avatar

jos

August 28th, 2005 at 5:57 pm

Headline says – BILLIONS IN FARM FUNDS USED FOR ARROYO CAMPAIGN! anak ka ng tatay mo… I GUESS YOUR OWN FATHER WOULD BE ASHAMED TO HAVE HAD YOU! We have been hearing about these in the past and now made official, we can only wonder and CRY that the bankcruptcy of once financially stable OWWA office… is brought about by a mere SMALL but TERRIBLE lady. The lady with an innocent, insensitive and icey smile. Hope you ENJOY the fruits of your LABOR, pwe!

Avatar

ANAK_NG_JUETENG

August 28th, 2005 at 8:15 pm

Headline says – BILLIONS IN FARM FUNDS USED FOR ARROYO CAMPAIGN!

Oh Man! The garci tapes and the Jueteng accusations are just ‘peanuts’
if you see this one. Is this still part of the tip of the iceberg or half
of the iceberg exposed ? I feel stupid if i insist that i am ‘stiil’ proud to
be a filipino. Sheeeeeeeeeshhhhh.

Avatar

pinaywriter

August 28th, 2005 at 9:23 pm

My unsolicited advice – please publish the names of the 103 congressmen and officials who took slice of the this billions pie.

Am i proud to be a filipino? No. It is going to be an uphill battle to get us to be morally upright. Forget GMA and so many of these people – they are where they are because — If we are to become an Asian Tiger, we need to be individually accountable. We need to be accountable, and holler when people are doing wrong.

Avatar

vonpogi

August 28th, 2005 at 11:02 pm

I am still proud to be Filipino? Kahit na anong sama ng ginawa nila ay pilipino pa rin tayo. Ang kailangan ay ituwid natin at bigyan ng example ang mga kabataan na susunod na magiging pinuno ng bansa natin. Dapat ipakita at ipakulong ang mga magnanakaw sa bayan. Lalo na ang nagpapahirap at mga walang kuwenteng “TONGRESSMAN”. Isa pa dapat rin ipakulong ang mga Heneral na hindi tumupad sa kanilang CODE of HONOR. We know na hindi natin kayang lumaban sa batas kahit na mag people power kung walang gabay ng mga sundalo. Kaya ang masasabi ko lang na kailangan natin ng tulong at gumising na ang mga matitinong sundalo natin lalo na ang mga Junior officer at huwag ninyo sundin ang mga Heneral na nagpasasa sa mga karumihan na gawain. Bakit kayo susunod doon sa utos nila, alam naman natin na walang kuwentang tao at hindi sila dapat nasa puwesto. Kailangan namin kayo (Junior Officer).

Avatar

benign0

August 29th, 2005 at 7:12 am

Well folks, that’s what we get for being proud for proud’s sake. Maybe it’s about time we put pride in its proper place — in the context of achievement as a CONCRETE basis for pride.

Tama na ang mga ‘proud to be Pinoy’ crap na yan. We have to ACHIEVE first as a nation before we can be proud.

For an example of that empty pride I speak of, check this out:

http://www.geocities.com/benign0/agr-disagr/16-1-ideo.html

Excerpt:

“We need to have something that would prove that the Philippine society is just more than an historical or fortuitous accident in order to justify its continued existence. We have to formulate some deeper ideology shared by all filipinos that would inspire personal or moral conviction beyond mere emotionalism or sentimentalism. Patriotism could only be sustained if it’s rooted on more timeless principles and yet peculiar only to the filipino people. Anything else, would be fleeting.”

Avatar

concerned citizen

August 29th, 2005 at 7:19 am

kasama sa mga kasalanan ni aroyo ang kanyang mga cabinet secretaties, mga corrupt generals & officers(hinde lahat), mga tongressmen & senators, mbc,(some) religious org na kampi sa kanya, media entities na bias, hypocrite elites & middle class na walang paki at iba pang nagbubulagbulagan at nagbibingibingihan. natotolerate nyo ang mga ganitong anomalies ni arroyo? sabagay kakunti na lang kayo 60 to 80% ng filipino ay ayaw na kay arroyo. kaya lang kapit tuko talaga dahil sa mga alipores nya na patuloy na sumusuporta sa mga kasalanan nya. pls lang gising mga kababayan. there’s still hope. IMPEACH ARROYO NOW!!!!

Avatar

soledad t. tubay

August 29th, 2005 at 9:25 am

I think I should confess and ask God to forgive me for murdering PGMA and her allies – in my mind. That’s what I want to do. Honestly. If only to get rid of them, after making them pay for their crimes to the people.

When can we really have true leaders? Leaders who are true servants of the people. Leaders who will not enrich themselves while in office. I remember one political candidate who is not from the elite class who vowed to have himself killed by musketry if he becomes wealthy after winning. Sana ganito talaga ang mangyari. Very ideal. Bakit kaya sina Randy David, Oscar Orbos … di maging mga senador o presidente kaya?

Avatar

m38manila

August 29th, 2005 at 7:50 pm

To be honest, and to the point, for all the waffle on ALL the blogs on this web site, BMA WILL survive until 2010. A reflection of the will of Filipino’s. There is no longer any will whatsoever for truth or justice. Get it out of your system to make you feel better by splattering your idealistic views, but accept the reality; – EDSA ‘s1 and 2 were classical manipulations of the “masses” by the well to do’s to get power into the hands they (the minority wealth-holders) felt would suit their needs. People power was nothing but wishful thinking, even Cory Aquino must realize that by now.

Avatar

cx

August 29th, 2005 at 10:29 pm

Mga Kababayan I want to share with you Gen. Norman Schwarzkopf famous ideology and principle.

“Let us now Judge Gloria, for you are not a Judge” (hehehehe)

Now for the serious one……..

“Forgiving Gloria Is God’s DUTY, Our Job Is Simply To Arrange The Meeting”

Don’t you agree?

I CALL FOR SNAP ELECTION, magka-alam alam lang kung sino talaga ang dapat na maupo sa bansa nating bankarote na nga eh natatapat pa sa mga Gahaman Maupo Agad, at Gahaman Magpayaman Agad.

Consitutional Successor si Noli, pero diba RUNNING MATE sila? Hindi kaya CHEAT MATES din sila so anong gagawin natin pagka-IMPEACH kay Gloria IMPEACH Noli aba, baka maging Republic of Impeachment na tayo niyan or WORSE, BANANA (republic) IMPEACHED THROUGH HOOLIGAN COHORTS sama ng acronym BITCH.

Avatar

mindanao

August 30th, 2005 at 3:41 am

PCIJ, are better than our local news.

Our Family once an avid reader of philippines star, but due to these events in politics, it is bias reading Phil Star news and opinions, Is the newspaper we have trusted have gone into GMA’s Payrolls. I am very sorry for Manong Max Soliven, the Star Captain of the boat.

We have already shifted to Inquirer, which is much better and seeks the truth.

To PCIJ, can you write articles what the cause of Phil Star , loss of dignity in delivering news to the people.

Ive heard Sonny Belmonte, one of the chief owner of the news is in solid GMA, tsk tsk. Sayang maganda pa naman ang Star….

Avatar

mindanao

August 30th, 2005 at 3:42 am

If only Teodoro Benigno is still Alive…. Phil Star will be still kicking…. I lost hope to the Philstar our family newspaper since elementary.

Avatar

primo

August 30th, 2005 at 9:32 am

di na ko masyadong nagbabasa san Star simula ng pumanaw si Mr. Teodoro Benigno (+) …. nakakainis basahin ang column ni max puro account tungkol kay GMA na kasama sya sa meeting etc etc… pwe!

Avatar

primo

August 30th, 2005 at 9:36 am

ating basahin ito.. ganda may pag asa….. di gaya ng isang nagpost d2 puro crap.. oo yung nag post d2 na gumagawa ng mga artikulo dun sa geocities.com..

this is worth reading.. from a very respected professor..

http://news.inq7.net/opinion/index.php?index=2&story_id=48321&col=60

Avatar

soledad t. tubay

August 30th, 2005 at 9:36 am

Kasi Star si GMA (that’s how she feels). A frustrated actress, but a trying hard copy cat.

Avatar

bisoy50

August 31st, 2005 at 8:13 am

As I understand that our country is comprising 7,100 islands, with all the (political) noise I’ve heard and read it seems that it is centered only in the capital. Does this means that the whole country are decided at the capital only? Maski anong ingay ang gagawin ninyo diyan hindi ninyo basta-basta makumbinsi ang natitirang lugar na kinabibilangan ng buong bayan. This was proven for so many times unless otherwise it will be again in martial rule. Even the coup de etat that had been exercised for so many times during so many country leaders, it doesn’t took effectively. Kabayan, ang geographical situations and locations of the 7,100 islands of our country is a big factor that whatever noise started at the capital will end up at the same level. With regards to poverty we cannot blame anyone but we ourselves are the main contributors of it. In what reason that I said so? Because, we are easily fooled by our sweet talking politician who made good promises during campaign period. Where in the world you can find that majority of the country leaders, lawmakers, etc., are former actors, actresses, showbiz personalities, basketball superstars? Answer: Only in da pilipins. Kabayan, please do not expect anything from these politicians. No one can erode corruption that is what politics is all about. If there’s any of it then it would not attract these celebrities turn politicians. Si o No?

Avatar

bisoy50

August 31st, 2005 at 8:26 am

Add on:

Ang masama pa ngayon everybody whnted to be the president. Particularly the last election (hard) losers, they can’t accept their losses and wait for the next election. Even if we kept on changing our president do you have any idea who are the best one to run our country? Ang unang lady president is not a person of politics but when she sit down on the presidency did anything changes on our country? I don’t think so since she was sorounded with the same dogs in a different collars. My personal advise Kabayan is there are only two choices 1) Is to live with it and go on with your daily lives. 2) Immigrate to a better country.

With all those impeachments nuissance citizen’s attention will be distracted with the real economic situation of our country. Pata-as ng pataas ang presyo ng gasolina siyempre sasabay ang presyo ng bilihin at manatiling nasa mababa ang pasahod at dahil nagkagulo ang taumbayan sa politika hindi ito mamalayan. Isang umaga magising na lang tayong tayo pala ang niloloko ng mga pulitikirong ito.

Patriotism and heroism gutom ang abutin natin kabayan, maniwala kayo at galing na ako diyan. Kaya pinili ko na lang ang manahimik sa isang sulok na buhay, hindi na nagutom, malusog, at tahimik.

Avatar

bisoy50

August 31st, 2005 at 8:49 am

Siguro magkaroon lang ng pagbabago ang bansa natin kun ang isang imposible mangyayari. Na mapapalitan ng bagong let us say new breed of politicians that doesn’t came from a family of politicians. Si Mr., si Mrs., si Junior, si bayaw, si pamangkin, si insan, pati na ang mga apo ay puro may posisyon na. Kaya imposible ngang mangyayari dahil ayaw na nilang bitawan ang impluwensang kanilang pinaghirapang ma build up. Well anyway, natural lang sa kustombre nating pilipino ang clanish di ba? So good luck na lang Juan de la Cruz.

At yung umaasa na sana makaupo si Ka Juan or Ka Pedro na kilalang mabuting tao hindi corrupt ay makapagbuti at magbigay nang pagbabago sa bayan. Mali kabayan dahil pag naupo na ang una or first order of business nila ay babaguhin nila ang buhay nila at sasabay na sila sa lipad ng mga traditional politicians siyempre ibinot mo e! Hindi ang inaasahan mong pagbabago sa ating bayan. It is just a routine, take your time and review some of them who are presently at the helm of power. Few of them are like Ka Juan and ka Pedro before fighting and crusading for the poor before their election. Whom we put our trust and hope. Look at them now you might even be confuse of what they are fighting for.

Kaya kabayan maski anong simbuti ng sinuman habang wala pa siya sa kapangyarihan pagdating ng araw bigla lang itong magbabago na mas mabilis pa sa instant coffe.

Avatar

selene

August 31st, 2005 at 1:06 pm

bisoy50,

You are quite a cynic but your posts are a breath of fresh air in a blog littered with inanities.

Regarding your comment about the importance of patriotism and heroism–I think it is TRUE patriotism and heroism that are lacking in our country. Siguro kaya tayo nagugutom in spite of all our professed love of country, is because our patriotism is wrongly misplaced. We bank on popularity instead of capacity–look at the clowns we elected in the previous elections.

The victory of GMA in the last elections was a stroke of good luck. Had it not been for voters of other candidates who later opted for GMA, FPJ would have been our president–a possibility that boded no good to our country. At most, GMA would have had a very close lead over FPJ.

We are now faced with the same possibility of clowns occupying the seat of power–the sour losers you mentioned are in the wings, all poised to pounce on the presidency once it is vacant. Let us not be blinded by their rhetoric into believing that they are even worth the positions they currently occupy.

GMA’s win was an epiphany; it brought about a realization that what we need to move this country forward is a predominance of intelligent, level-headed and realistic people who are not governed by their emotions, who are not easily swayed by the theatrics of these ambitious and unscrupulous characters.

Your advice [i.e. 1) to live with it or 2) immigrate to a better country] is well-taken. If I may add a third–frustrate these people causing the impeachment nuisance. They are the ones bringing our country down–sour losers with no better alternative for the nation.

If, instead of expecting superhuman capacities from our leaders, we thought more in terms of INVESTING our time and resources towards the economic development of our country, we would be widening our own options to more than just these two–living with “it” or immigrating to a better country.

The impeachment nuisance is a waste of time and resources, time and resouces that could be better spent by Congress, by the government, and by the nation as a whole, in improving the economy.

Avatar

manunga

August 31st, 2005 at 1:29 pm

a cynic that is a breath of fresh air????

the VICTORY???? of GMA???? a stroke of good luck???? an epiphany????

implying that to expect honesty and decency and efficiency from our goverment is to expect “superhuman capacities from our leaders”?????????????

yan ang inaninities!!!

and to conclude that those supporting impeachment are ruled by emotion rather than intelligence… oh c’mon… unang una ano nga bang masama sa pagiging emosyonal tungkol sa mga nangyayari sa bansa? second, to have emotions about an issue DOES NOT preclude one from being able to think rationally at the same time. Intellect and emotion are two human faculties that are not mutually exclusive, my dears! Pwedeng gamitin yun ng sabay… Maybe you don’t know how to do that kaya ganito ang mga sinasabi niyo…

Hay naku, practice what you preach na lang kaya? Take your own advice, why dontcha? :)

Avatar

enlightened_pinay

August 31st, 2005 at 1:38 pm

To Selene,
instead of expecting superhuman capacities from our leaders, we thought more in terms of INVESTING our time and resources towards the economic development of our country.
————
This is a very vague solution. Do you know how can we achieve this? Do you think the Filipinos are capable to do this?

The result of this impeachment proceedingswill reflect if our leaders, and if the nation as a whole are ready to leave the old ways that have been put us into poverty & desolation.

Avatar

gungonguli

August 31st, 2005 at 1:42 pm

Napakadaming kalokohan ng gobyernong ito,dapat hndi nating hayaan na matuoy ang chacha sa sila ang nasa kapangyarihan,paiikutin lang tyo ng mga to

Avatar

selene

September 1st, 2005 at 3:27 pm

enlightened_pinay,

What if the results of the impeachment proceedings go in favor of Arroyo? Will we be able to deal with it? Or will we be taking to the streets again?

How we will react to the outcome of the impeachment will reflect our maturity as a people. Will we accept the results of the impeachment process, regardless of whether or not it is what we want? Are we mature enough to accept the political nature of the impeachment process?

Yes, I think we are very much capable of investing our time and resources towards the economic development of our country. We just have wrong priorities. We spend our time trying to oust a hardworking president; meanwhile, we are losing the export wars. There are over four thousand bills awaiting the attention of Congress; its time is better spent on those. We keep touting our idealism; isn’t it time we thought of making money? We spend our time whining about the government; yet how productive are we?

The solution I have stated isn’t a vague one; we just have to look within ourselves–we’ve done too much looking around us already.

Avatar

selene

September 1st, 2005 at 3:41 pm

manunga,

One thing I have noticed in various forums is the inability of some posters to handle criticism. Proof of emotions ruling over intellect.

Avatar

manunga

September 1st, 2005 at 4:12 pm

ergo… we go round and round and round…

Thing is, if you do not want to participate in the call for impeachment that’s your choice. As is the choice to do so is mine. We can try to dissuade each other all we want, but if you think disagreeing with someone’s opinion is the same as “inability … to handle criticism” and/or “proof of emotions ruling over intellect” then at least with you, the only thing left to do is to agree to disagree.

But you know, thanks for giving me a glimpse as to how ordinary people, and much more those bastards in congress, only see form over substance.

In the end, the real work is not in this blog, is it? This is just a small part of what needs to be done (or undone…) We can argue till we’re blue in the face but unless we actually practice what we preach, pare-parehas lang tayong lahat no matter which side we’re on. The thing is pagdating sa action, the anti-impeachment and/or pro-GMA guys have one up over the rest of us. Why? kasi all they want to do is, well, NOTHING. And there’s the rub!

Avatar

enlightened_pinay

September 1st, 2005 at 4:23 pm

Selene,
ang dami mong tinanong, you just want me to make speculations sa mga hindi pa nangyayari eh hindi naman ako manghuhula. thats why kailangan nang matuloy ang impeachment so that everything will be presented in the proper court, para we won’t need to make anymore speculations. actually going back to your question, im speculating that if we will have an honest impeachment using the ammended complaint, there is no way Arroyo can win this.

bakit ayaw mong mag impeachment? ayaw mo bang ma i defend ng idol mo ang sarili nya.

opinyon mo hardworking president si Arroyo, i respect that. pero opinyon ko din na yes hardworking nga sya, hardworking syang mangdaya sa eleksyon at mangurakot sa pera ng bayan. at opinyon ko din peke syang presidente.

Ang sabi mo, there are over four thousand bills awaiting the attention of Congress. Ilang taon bang nakaupo yang si Gloria mo, mag lilimang taon na sa january di ba. kelan lang nagsimula ang impeachment hearing, di ba etong july lang. so wag mong sisihin ang impeachment proceeding, gumising ka.

Ang sabi mo — we just have to look within ourselves–we’ve done too much looking around us already. Sabihin mo kay Arroyo yan at sa mga alipores nya. Nasagot ko na to before sa previous blog ko. Matino na akong nagbabayad ng tax, 30% infact ang nababawas sa sweldo ko, hindi ako mandaraya at magnanakaw. Gusto ko ang boss ko sa trabaho, ang mga leaders ko, lalo na ang presidente ko ganun din. Araw araw akong chi-ne-check, malinis pa naman ang konsensya ko. Kaya stop making that clicheist comment anymore, matagal nang laos yan.

Avatar

kikz

September 2nd, 2005 at 12:17 pm

Who the hell is saying GLORIA MACAPAL ARROYO este MACAPAGAL is hardworking? Hardworking doesn’t warrant a good president and effective president… Nor it suggests upright, morally and president with integrity that we as a people can emulate. Absolutely…NO….

Maybe GLORIA is hardworking in coercing congress, comelec, senate and other independent government institutions? Busy in making laws baluktot to side them. Busing in making this country immoral and no sense of integrity…Busy in spending and corrupting peoples money (including the taxes I pay w/c is almost 35K per month)…Busy in bluffing the filipino people about truth…I’m correct, right…

I am very strong with my belief and I always repeated this that we HAVE A FAKE PRESIDENT…

Avatar

masha

September 2nd, 2005 at 12:41 pm

time for the guillotine for gma and her ilk. whoosh away!

Avatar

masha

September 2nd, 2005 at 12:42 pm

criticism criticism pa. wala na yan. time to do what we should have done years ago: get rid of the oligarchy.

Avatar

selene

September 6th, 2005 at 6:44 pm

manunga and enlightened_pinay,

If the opposition can come up with the 79 signatures needed to send their case to the Senate, then there is nothing to prevent an impeachment trial. Let GMA then defend herself at trial.

Otherwise, respect the decision of the majority affirming the decision of the justice committee dismissing the three complaints.

The question is: can the Gloria Ibagsak people handle it if the opposition do not get the 79 signatures? Can they respect the decision of the majority or will they be taking to the streets again if they do not get their way?

It is a shame that being lawmakers, their first resort, instead of immediately filing an impeachment complaint, was to take to the streets and clamor for Arroyo’s resignation. The so-called amended complaint was a mere afterthought when they found out that they could not gain enough public support for their evil designs. Pinahiya pa nila ang mga sarili nila by throwing that despicable tantrum in Congress. How could they expect to win their colleagues over to their side?

Their hodgepodge of an impeachment complaint, their arrogance in calling themselves the conscience bloc, as if they had the monopoly of truth, their intolerance of the views of their colleagues, their tainted motives and their overeager desire to oust Arroyo are ingredients for defeat. We need not look to the other side of the fence if the so-called “conscience bloc” screws up.

Avatar

enlightened_pinay

September 6th, 2005 at 7:11 pm

Selene,
Dont fool yourself, its not the minority’s fault why the impeachment failed. With what happened in congress during the past few days, now everyone know that its not a question of whether you’re in the side of what is right, for truth & justice. Its a question of who has the stronger political machinery. And dont accuse me of making false judgement because I personally know someone who works for a party list group in congress who said that their group was demanded by Arroyo’s group to be re-organized only to ensure that their representative will vote YES to the trashing of the impeachment complaints.

Avatar

kavenishi

September 6th, 2005 at 7:28 pm

enlightened_pinay said,
September 6, 2005 @ 7:11 pm

Selene,
Dont fool yourself, its not the minority’s fault why the impeachment failed.
********************************************************************

enlightened_pinay,

Can i ask you question? why the party list group or minority congressman did not file impeachment complain in the first place. Bakit naunahan pa sila ni Atty. Lozano. Kaya naman pala nilang gumawa ng ammended complain bakit tatanga-tanga sila nung lumabas na yung Garci tape hindi sila nagfile ng impeachment complain agad. Ano umaasa ba sila noon sa shortcut na mapapatalsik si PGMA sa pamamagitan ng People power. At nung walang masyadong kumagat sa People power nagmamadaling nagfile ng ammended complain.
I agree with almost everybody here na ni-railroad yung process ng mga maka-administration, pero dahil din sa kagagawan ng minority eh. Binigyan nila ng butas ang reklamo nila. Dahil sa tatanga-tanga sa umpisa at umaasa sa people power, ayan tuloy walang nangyari.

Avatar

noelet

September 6th, 2005 at 7:43 pm

kanaveshi,

ask this in parallel: why did lozano filed that complaint without assesing evidence, first? and why marcoleta endorsed without investigating its substance and form?

ask that first, beacuse that’s the first in the events of things that lead today.

the opposition did not file late. and its not thier fault. now why the need to beat them in the filing?

that’s the proper question.

Avatar

kavenishi

September 6th, 2005 at 7:58 pm

Lozano filed it because he believes that the Garci tape is impeachable offense…Marcoleta endorsed it because he believes to the complain or no one is endorsing it.
So who’s to blame? It should be Lozano and Marcoleta and not the anti-impeachment in that case. So the Pro impeachment congressman should blame Lozano and Marcoleta and not the Administration. So to the pro-impeachment look for Lozano and marcoleta kill them both, because your impeachment complain was killed initially by this two person.

Avatar

koj

September 6th, 2005 at 7:59 pm

history na ang lahat, lozano complaint, pre-empting the opposition…opposition believing so much that a domino effect (people power) will happen if they go to the streets….congressmen pataasan ng ihi at baho sa congress…railroading of the complaint….

umpisa pa lang, alam nila na duon talaga patungo ang complaint…sa simenteryo…or impiyerno, whatever your take…

opposition are down to their last few cards, marching to the streets is the next option…but then again…alam na rin nila kung saan papunta ‘to.

Avatar

kavenishi

September 6th, 2005 at 8:02 pm

pakisama na rin pala si Congressman Suplico kasi kasama rin siyang nagendorse sa Lozano complaint.

Avatar

enlightened_pinay

September 6th, 2005 at 8:32 pm

kaveneshi,
have you been following this impeachment process all along?

naintindihan nyo po ba na hindi dapat nila binasura ng justice committee ang opposition & Lopez complaints dahil imbes na unahin nila ang question of form of substance ay inuna pa nila ang prejudicial question. naiintindihan nyo rin po ba na may mga experts na nag sasabi na ayun sa constitution, hinahayaan tayong magkaron ng ISA LAMANG IMPEACHMENT PROCEEDING SA ISANG TAON, ang complaint po ay iba sa proceeding.

Ang justice committe ay may choice sana, pero pinatay nila ang pagkakaton ng mga tao na marinig at makita ang ebidensya ng magkabilang panig.

Avatar

kavenishi

September 6th, 2005 at 8:45 pm

enlightened_pinay said,
September 6, 2005 @ 8:32 pm

kaveneshi,
have you been following this impeachment process all along?

naintindihan nyo po ba na hindi dapat nila binasura ng justice committee ang opposition & Lopez complaints dahil imbes na unahin nila ang question of form of substance ay inuna pa nila ang prejudicial question. naiintindihan nyo rin po ba na may mga experts na nag sasabi na ayun sa constitution, hinahayaan tayong magkaron ng ISA LAMANG IMPEACHMENT PROCEEDING SA ISANG TAON, ang complaint po ay iba sa proceeding.

Ang justice committe ay may choice sana, pero pinatay nila ang pagkakaton ng mga tao na marinig at makita ang ebidensya ng magkabilang panig.

*********************************************************************

I absolutely agree with you. mali yung mga administration congressman. kaso hindi tayo congressman eh, sila yung nagpasya nun kaya yun ang paniniwala nila. lutong makaw man ang impeachment process, what to do. congress is about numbers, not about what is right or wrong. is about political affiliation. so next time, or next election bumoto naman tayo ng mabuti. tayo rin naman ang naglagay sa kanila jan eh. so tayo rin dapat ang sisihin. wag tayong magmalinis, it’s all our fault…

Avatar

koj

September 6th, 2005 at 8:55 pm

eh paano yan…enlightened_pinay, the constitution gave congress the authority to create their own rules…and certainly the congressmen created their own rules which may not be to our own liking cause it represents only their own best self interest.

bakit hindi ginawang malinaw ng mga framers ang constitution para hindi magiging open to other interpretations…the experts, some framers, some are not, obviously have their say and let’s respect that. but they are not the only framers of this constitution, who knows maybe their views, highly logical and intellectual it may be, were not adopted by the majority of the delegates, and eventually, just ended as their views. maybe opening the transcripts would reveal the proper intentions of the provisions…o baka naman, kinopya na lng verbatim sa previous cons…

we can go run to the supreme court as final arbiter, but obviously the critics are already waiting what they would say, may it be positive or negative…damned if you do, damned if you don’t…

Avatar

noelet

September 6th, 2005 at 8:57 pm

the put a microscope in your views. as little as lozano and marcoleta – they two are just part of the grand plan. why would you say that malacanan is innocent?

Avatar

noelet

September 6th, 2005 at 9:01 pm

what is logically lacking in the impeachment process is the transparency of an investigation that mmust be and should be separate form the proceedings in congress – that would give it an apolitical sense.

Avatar

koj

September 6th, 2005 at 9:08 pm

unfortunately impeachment (specially removal of an elected position) is (going to be) a political excercise and nothing else. it is for that reason most will go with their own political ties.

Avatar

kavenishi

September 6th, 2005 at 9:15 pm

noelet said,
September 6, 2005 @ 8:57 pm

the put a microscope in your views. as little as lozano and marcoleta – they two are just part of the grand plan. why would you say that malacanan is innocent?

*********************************************************************
I did not say malacanang is innocent. Of course they are guilty of garci tape, cover-up (hello gary tape) and all the accusations about cheating.
I believe also FPJ did win the election and PGMA really cheated, but i don’t have enough evidence. The garci tape cannot be use as evidence in court . I also believe maybe yes Lozano and marcoleta maybe have contacts in malacanang. But i don’t like about the opposition and minority congressman, they are making monopoly about the truth. As if they were holy and saints. Nagmamalinis masyado. That’s why i don’t like them. I hate PGMA but i hate more those self-rightousness opposition congressmen. They always saying if you will not sign the impeachment complain your against the truth. No, if you will not sign the impeachment you want still PGMA to remain in office. If you sign the impeachment complain your not with the truth as the opposition claims, your with the people who wants PGMA out of the office. Nobody can claim that they own the truth, why the opposition misleading the people and use the word “TRUTH” on their cause. Is not the truth they are seeking, but the ouster of PGMA. Be honest and don’t be hypocrite.
I like PGMA out but i don’t like the opposition to replace her. I want a new face, but i don’t know that new face exist.

Avatar

noelet

September 6th, 2005 at 10:36 pm

kavenishi, you don’t have enough evidence? this is nonsense… for you are not the court either. so do you say that the tapes are still inadmissible?

Avatar

korab

September 6th, 2005 at 10:54 pm

tapos na boksing……sumuko na kayo…patay na impeachment(na-imagine ko si Tessie Oreta na sumasayaw..hehehe)..kung gusto nyo dalhin nyo na lang sa lansangan, para mas maraming mabuwisit sa inyo dahil sa trapik

Avatar

masha

September 6th, 2005 at 10:59 pm

the truth is the truth regardless who sides with it. just because you do not like the people who are looking for the truth this time doesnt mean the truth is not worth delving into. sablay, man.

Avatar

masha

September 6th, 2005 at 11:01 pm

conversely lies are lies regardless of whether you like the person who propagates it. it is morally decrepit to accept/side with lies just because you do not like the people who side with the truth.

Avatar

noelet

September 6th, 2005 at 11:05 pm

kavenishi, your wanting something that doesn’t exist… you know the best solution is to sedate yourself and be numb?

Avatar

noelet

September 6th, 2005 at 11:10 pm

the truth is something you search before you find. you need to exert effort and energy. now the opposition gives ys that muscle that you people cannot and will definitely fail in doing.

give credit to where its due. after all we liken this to a sarsuela or a telenovela – but not to a beauty pageant… that’s too much.

Avatar

koj

September 6th, 2005 at 11:20 pm

everyone knows gma cheated…everyone also knows the opps cheated as well…many knows walang kahinatnan ang impeachment due to its political nature…many believed and resigned to the idea that in case gma is ousted, another clone (may it be from admin or opps) would do no better…when people think this way, they would not mind anything that’s been happening around them as long as it doesn’t affect them.

sans the politicians, marching the streets might achieve results somehow to change people’s perspective in the way the people vote (pero tagal pa next election its effectiveness would die down) and being vigilant to actions of their elected leaders. but if it can oust the president, i doubt it…not this time around…

Avatar

noelet

September 7th, 2005 at 12:13 am

koj are you jok(ing)?

is trying to be in the middle of these divisive political atmosphere youre sense of style? trying to promote a spectator ideas? the middle-righteousness?

everyone knows gma cheated is not the same as oppositon cheated as well. know your story.the fact that we have a crisis is because you are very very wrong.

cheating is prevalent. indeed.

but not as grandscale as the last 2004 election as liken to the 86′ snap election. when you buy votes, when bribe comelec… that is cheating. but when you command comelec to cheat, you command the military to aid you in your quest for immortalization, when you purposely use government’s BILLION worth of funds for your personal campaign, when you buy congressmen… then lay in silence and compare that to your claim of cheating made by the opposition.

by the way… who is your opposition? or what you say “opposition” is your idea of the general politician? are you saying that you have evidences to show that the pro-impeachment congressmen cheated last election?

or are you talking about the general atmosphere? you may not know what you are talking about.

very misleading…

Avatar

koj

September 7th, 2005 at 12:34 am

the reason we have a crisis is because they were caught and in power…what sense would it be to cry foul if the opps were caught cheating when they are not in power anyway….

my idea is that everyone cheated may it be small or grand scale (some can’t do grand scale if they don’t have the means), don’t overanalyze my post…

i’m not trying to be righteous (if you brand the middle class that way). on the other hand i believe you’re the one trying to be one.

Avatar

selene

September 7th, 2005 at 6:30 pm

Saw the following ad in the Inquirer yesterday…

MESSAGE TO CONGRESSMEN
FROM OVER 600 TOP INDEPENDENT WOMEN IN CIVIL SOCIETY:

1.GMA IS STILL THE BEST OPTION VS. CHAOS AND ANARCHY.

2.LET’S SUPPORT GMA’S CONSTITUTIONAL MANDATE TO MOVE OUR COUNTRY FORWARD AND TAKE ITS RIGHTFUL PLACE IN ASIA. Masyado na tayong napag-iiwanan.

3.OUR COUNTRY CANNOT MOVE FORWARD IF WE TAKE TO THE STREETS. IF THE OPPOSITION CALLS FOR PEOPLE POWER, WE WON’T LEAD AND WE WON’T FOLLOW. WE BELIEVE THAT REAL PEOPLE EMPOWERMENT LIES IN BEING UNITED AND WORKING TOGETHER TO SOLVE THE ENORMOUS PROBLEMS OF OUR COUNTRY.

4.DON’T WASTE YOUR PRECIOUS VOTE FOR IMPEACHMENT IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES PLENARY SESSION. DON’T SEND THE COMPLAINT FOR TRIAL IN THE SENATE BECAUSE IT WOULD ENTAIL MORE THAN ONE YEAR OF DEBATES. THIS WOULD PARALYZE CONGRESS AND FURTHER DAMAGE THE ECONOMY.

CONCERNED FILIPINOS’ DECALOGUE – AUGUST 2005
WE LOVE OUR COUNTRY AND WE FIRMLY BELIEVE:

•That united, we can earn the esteem of the community of nations;

•That our government can come up with a citizenry that is decently fed, clothed, sheltered, and schooled;

•That media—objective but inspiring, critical yet encouraging—can be constructive partners in nation-building, providing an environment in which Filipino talent will flourish and serve society at large;

•That our people, with the above basics, can become productive, fulfilled individuals, proud of being Filipinos, content to remain in the land of their birth;

•That President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo (PGMA) as our duly elected president, with the Constitutional right and duty to serve out her term, can with God’s grace and our help bring about the above situation;

•That the present unsubstantiated charges hurled against PGMA with illegally obtained “evidence” presented by people of questionable repute are flimsy grounds that cannot merit a demand for her resignation;

•That to negate the damage done to PGMA’s position, the accusations vs. PGMA undergo a fair legal process that can serve to unite all Filipinos toward nationhood;

•That the painful political siege PGMA has been subjected to can strengthen her resolve to pursue reforms with greater determination;

•That quick fixes and extra-legal power grabs can never offer any lasting solutions to political and other woes;

•That with time and sweat, tears and pain, patience and determination, we can with God’s help bring about our redemption.

It’s on page A4 of yesterday’s issue. The signatures mainly belong to ladies of integrity, who are known to take an independent, level-headed stand on government and political issues, and who are advocates for constructive solutions to the problems our country is facing. It just shows that GMA continues to enjoy the support of civil society, contrary to claims of her detractors.

Avatar

kikz

September 8th, 2005 at 12:51 pm

RELIEVED and elated by the decision of the House of Representatives to dismiss the three impeachment complaints filed against her, President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo urged the nation Tuesday to “move on to a brighter tomorrow.” She hailed the 158-51 vote upholding the recommendation of the House justice committee as a “grand display of political maturity” by the congressmen and said it “seals our stability and resilience as a nation.” That day, she added, was “a glorious day in history” that saw a President being retained “through voting in the halls of constitutional democracy” instead of being ousted through people power.

It would have been more fitting to call it Gloria’s day. For only the President and her loyal allies seemed in the mood to celebrate the results of the vote last Tuesday, much less toast the mindless loyalty that her congressional allies put on display.

The Constitution gives the House all of 60 session days to discuss and decide impeachment complaints. The justice committee finished its work in 14 days, 12 of which were wasted on debating anything and everything but the very serious charges made against the President, including cheating in and stealing the last presidential elections. When it buckled down to real business, the committee set aside the stronger amended complaint put together by the opposition, and chose to consider the poorly prepared complaint filed by lawyer Oliver Lozano, saying it was the first to be filed.

Some legal luminaries had pointed out that what was barred by the Constitution was not the filing of other complaints but a second impeachment proceeding within one year. But pro-administration members of the committee insisted they were one and the same. Then they threw out the original Lozano complaint for “insufficiency of substance.”

The House as a whole could have overturned that funny committee decision by a vote of one-third of its members, but Malacañang saw to it that the opposition couldn’t gather the 79 votes they needed. Calls were reportedly made to congressmen, pork barrel funds increased, high positions offered or actually given to relatives and friends of lawmakers and other promises made to ensure that they voted against impeachment. And but for one party-list congressman (who would later withdraw his signature from the impeachment complaint), no one found anything wrong with such blatant attempts to influence and corrupt the members of a supposedly co-equal body as well as the impeachment process.

When it was time for the entire House to vote, the reasons most often cited by administration lawmakers for trashing the impeachment was that it was what their constituents wanted. How did they come to that conclusion when surveys have shown that a big majority of Filipinos want Ms Arroyo impeached?

Another reason given was that the impeachment is a political process and so they must toe the party line. If this were so, then impeachment is a toothless and useless process. A president, who has a firm hold on the majority in Congress, can commit any crime without fear of losing his position. Conversely, a president that doesn’t have a majority can be removed for the flimsiest of reasons.

Strangely, this notion that impeachment is nothing more than a numbers game has gained currency. And that is how the administration allies in the House played it. And they call such slavish, mindless loyalty a “grand display of political maturity”? What the House vote last Tuesday showed was not democracy in action but the failure to function of the one institutional process to redress wrongdoing in the highest office.

When the President challenged her political foes to “bring their grievance to Congress,” many welcomed it, assuming she was willing to submit to the process (laid down by the Constitution) of determining wrongdoing at the highest levels of government. But it looks like she and her allies quickly moved to subvert it.

Now the process of ascertaining the truth and seeking justice is back to where it was before she hurled that challenge—in the streets. And many among those who thought our laws and institutions should be given the chance to work are starting to link hands with those who had declared from the start that such avenue was closed. Ms Arroyo may think the worst is over, but very few others see a “brighter tomorrow” of peace and stability in the days or even months ahead.

Avatar

basher

September 8th, 2005 at 4:36 pm

Whats happening to the people? Everything is all out in terms of evidence!! And all we get are more evidence and an acquitted Impeachment case. If she is really innocent, why doesn’t she prove it! Now is the real time to go to the streets, the real time where we are robbed of the littlest pennies that we make. Kitang kita naman sa figures, in terms of debt, projects, and ofcourse all the exposes. TANGINA! baba ka na ate glow! pati pera ng mga maliliit na tao, inexploit mo! What happened to danding cojuangco when the coco levi issue arose? hindi bat this is of the same genre, money of the people, becomes money of the freakin corrupt politicians!! Military people wake up!! now is the time to make your stand!! Ibagsak si Gloria!

Avatar

kikz

September 9th, 2005 at 12:30 pm

basher — correct ko lang ng konti — hindi po ate glow but ATE GLUE…
Kapit tuko na kasi… kapal muks…

TAX REVOLT…..

Iwan ko lang kung hindi ‘tong si ATE GLUE malaglag sa puwesto…
Ganun di naman, yung tulong natin sa gobyerno sa pamamagitan ng pagbabayad ng buwis ay pinagbayad lang naman ni ATE GLUE sa mga tongressmen na kaalyado nya para makuha ang support… Lalong lalo ng ngayon binasura nila ang empeachment mas lalong expensive dahil e-maintain ni ATE GLUE yung support ng mga tongressmen…Kaya nga meron silang tinatawag na — it’s PAYBACK TIME….

Kaya panawagan ko po sa lahat — TAX REVOLT….

Avatar

marubdob

September 9th, 2005 at 12:58 pm

kikz,

can you give us an idea on how to go about the tax revolt that you are suggesting.

Avatar

selene

September 9th, 2005 at 7:38 pm

Tax revolt, rallies, who are you kidding? Sino ba maaapektuhan niyan? Sino ba mawawalan ng trabaho? Sino ang magdurusa? Ang mayayamang pulitiko? Inuuto nyo sarili nyo. It’s the economy that will suffer. Ang mga manggagawa ang magdurusa. Get out of your comfort zones and false ideologies and see the average worker who desires nothing but to move on with his life. Do you think he cares kung sino ang pangulo? No! All he wants is a stable job, food on the table and a better life for his family. Either your eyes and ears were closed to the majority congressmen’s speeches in Congress and you listened only to those of the minority, or you are truly the ones who are deaf, dumb and blind to the real truth and to the real will of the majority of Filipinos.

Avatar

gagay

September 9th, 2005 at 7:52 pm

oy selene hindi mo matatakot ang mga tao dito sa mga pinagsasabi mo. di sila uto utong tulad mo. uto utong sa pekeng presidente.

Avatar

ejam

September 9th, 2005 at 9:43 pm

Selene u have lost ur sense of what is right and wrong.

It is wrong to cheat and lie.

The only way we can move forward is to safeguard the fundamentals of our Democracy. We follow the Constitution, have clean elections and have leaders who are accountable to the people. If everyone follows the rules from the top all the way down, then we can project a stable, economically/politically level playing field.

As opposed to a personality driven, GMA is the only option kind of crap that u want ram down our throats.

Oh and the copy of the ad that you posted, it’s pointless.

Avatar

noelet

September 9th, 2005 at 10:41 pm

dear selene,

did you happen to listen to the minority’s speeches? uuhuhuuuy aminin… kutsikutsikoo.

Avatar

ejam

September 10th, 2005 at 12:07 am

” Get out of your comfort zones and false ideologies and see the average worker who desires nothing but to move on with his life.”
______________________________________________________________________

What comfort zones? What false ideologies? Who doesn’t want to move on in life? Wag kang masyadong OA.

Your typical Filipino mentality as shown in your arguments is what makes the Philppines the crummy, filthy, laughable, shameful country that it is right now.

Go back to basics.

Down with this Fascist Regime! Give the Government back to the people!

Avatar

ejam

September 11th, 2005 at 12:59 am

So what do you do, apart from write on messageboards?

Avatar

INSIDE PCIJ: Stories behind our stories » ANAD analyzed

November 9th, 2005 at 6:30 pm

[…] If ANAD, an anti-communist group, somehow rings a bell, it’s because we had a post months ago at the height of the "Gloriagate" scandal about certain party-list organizations that were mentioned in the taped conversations allegedly between Pres. Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo and former elections commissioner Virgilio Garcillano. […]

Avatar

EntelliMedia » Blog Archive » … to find out that the mainstream media

February 23rd, 2007 at 1:34 pm

[…] INSIDE PCIJ ” Messing with the party list … forward is a predominance of intelligent, level-headed and realistic people who … That media “objective but inspiring, critical yet encouraging “can be … […]

Comment Form