PRESIDENT Arroyo has fired Juan Miguel Luz as education undersecretary in what appears to be the fallout from the Department of Education’s refusal to accept three postdated checks Malacañang had released for Zambales Rep. Antonio Diaz’s scholarship program at the height of the congressional hearings on the impeachment complaint against her.

Luz, Deped undersecretary for finance, has said that postdated checks are not allowed in government.

Executive Secretary Eduardo Ermita announced Luz’s relief in an interview with journalists this afternoon. He gave no reason, simply saying it was the president’s prerogative to replace her appointees.

Ermita said a letter had been sent to the DepEd undersecretary thanking him for his services. He added that Luz, a career executive service officer (CESO), will be transferred somewhere else, but did not say to which office. 

There was no immediate reaction from Luz, who returned earlier this week from an overseas trip.

DepEd sources expressed surprise at the Palace’s announcement, saying the education undersecretary never submitted any resignation letter to Arroyo.

His relief raises questions over the status of civil servants named to important government positions under the Arroyo administration.

Luz, who became a CESO when he joined the Aquino government as a director of the Presidential Management Staff, is guaranteed security of tenure under civil service rules. This means that unlike political appointees who are non-career officers, he does not serve at the pleasure of the president.

The postdated checks for Diaz’s scholars, totaling P15 million, came from the President’s Social Fund and were believed tied to Palace maneuvers to trash the impeachment complaint against Arroyo.  The Palace had also issued a current-dated check worth P5 million for the same program.

DepEd was named payee in all checks, raising suspicions that the Palace was using the agency to launder money for legislators who had pledged their support to the president.

Diaz, a member of the Liberal Party that had earlier called for Arroyo’s resignation, was among the 158 congressmen who voted last Sept. 6 to approve the House justice committee report junking the complaint.

Malacañang has since gotten back the postdated checks it issued to DepEd.

70 Responses to Palace fires uncooperative DepEd undersecretary

Avatar

Andrew Stimmens Marahombsar-Colayko

September 23rd, 2005 at 8:30 pm

You see,

Gloria’s Gloria’s Move…

You have to take note Mrs Pseudo President:

The Filipinos Eyes are watching your step…

You are totally eradicating honest people in your government…

Be not afraid!!!!

Avatar

baycas

September 23rd, 2005 at 8:44 pm

re: arroyo’s hold-on-to-the-stolen-power agenda…

reward the acquiescent, punish the stubborn.

retain the compliant, purge the disobedient.

save the favorable, eliminate the hostile.

and so it goes on…and on…and on…

Avatar

Partisanong Lagalag

September 23rd, 2005 at 10:58 pm

Malacanang simply doesn’t run out of shitloads…it just keeps on coming.

Avatar

mukilteo

September 24th, 2005 at 12:55 am

the recent moves that the president have made obviously is intended to rid the government of honest, law abiding personnels to perpetuate her corrupt hold to power. I can discern that the country will again revert to martial law and suppress oppossition to her way of governance at the expense of the people, rich or poor. The people need to show her that she needs to go in any way possible and at any cost .

Avatar

tomas tinio

September 24th, 2005 at 1:34 am

To use the words of Bill Bennett, it seems to me GMA is not only “corrupt,” she is “corrupting.” Corrupting ang influence niya kay NSA Gonzales. Ganito rin ang mensaheng ipinaabot niya sa iba pang mga namumuno sa pamahalaan gaya nitong Undersec. Mabuti na lang may guaranteed security of tenure yung tao. Palagay ko chemically induced na lang ang tulog na na-eenjoy nitong si GMA at ng kanyang mga alagad.

Avatar

zorros

September 24th, 2005 at 5:02 am

GMA should be fired for issuing scrupulous post-dated checks.

Sino kaya ang mga scholar’s ni Diaz?? Biba Hot Vabes?

Avatar

tongue in, anew

September 24th, 2005 at 5:18 am

Iba talaga ang pangulo ng Pilipinas! Wala ng tatalo sa katalinuhan ni Gloria. Dapat talagang presidente ng UN. Biruin mo ginamit ang ang Dept. of Education para sa money laundering! Kaya ninyo ‘yon?

Teka….di ba pag post-dated, ibig sabihin wala nang pondo? Waaaa! Naubos na talaga.

Avatar

concerned citizen

September 24th, 2005 at 6:41 am

kung sino pa yung matitino yun ang tinatanggal. ang mga bugok na reretain. syempre “birds of the same feather flock together”. ok magsama sama kayong mga mga magnanakaw gaya ni gonzales ayun tigas ang suporta ng malakanyang sa kapwa nya magnanakaw ng pera ng bayan. itong deped official na hinde ma take kawanglanghiyan ni arroyo ayun nangyari sa kanya tanggal. di pwede matino dito sa gobyerno ni arroyo. ang gobyerno ni arroyo ay pugad ng mga ibon na pare pareho ang lipad. sana pagdating ng panahon ang bagsak nyo ay malakas na lagapak. may araw din kayo. GOD IS WATCHING YOU!

Avatar

emer

September 24th, 2005 at 7:17 am

gustto siguro ni gloria puro kalahi nya na walanghiya ang nandyan sa gobyerno kaya tinanggal di undersecreatary Luz. kapal mo talaga gloria

Avatar

Toro

September 24th, 2005 at 8:51 am

The shit hits the fan again.

Avatar

Dodie

September 24th, 2005 at 10:33 am

kilala ko si mike, dati kong boss sa pms nung panahon ni cory… & he’ll never exchange his principle to anything. kung ano ang kanyang paninindigan batay sa kung ano ang reglamento ‘yun ang kanyang titintigan. alam ko maraming mga taga-deped ang matutuwa sa kanyang pagalis… matutuwa ‘yung mga magnanakaw at miyembro ng sindikato.
saludo pa rin ako sa ‘yo boss mike!
and to hell with gloria!!!

Avatar

ring

September 24th, 2005 at 10:55 am

time is running out for this government..

Let the change begin…Time to act..

Time is now…

Avatar

Dodie

September 24th, 2005 at 11:12 am

tama ka ring… “Let the change begin…Time to act..Time is now…” kaya mas pakalatin pa natin ang pcij.blog at ng maraming magpahayag ng damdamin.
Ang siste, papano nga naman ‘yung ‘alang cp at alang access sa internet?..txt brigade. ‘eh ‘yung alang celfone? bulong brigade! ok, let’s do it…ipasa ang bulong na ito hanggang makarating sa teynga ni gloria: GLORIA, LAYAS NA!!!

Avatar

bangus

September 24th, 2005 at 11:40 am

We blame GLORIA, the congressmen, senators, but come election time PEOPLE will still vote for them. Same cycle, same situation- same complaints, same move to oust her, same impeachment, etc., etc.

If PING LACSON agreed to run as Vice President with FPJ, they would have won by not less than 1million votes even with MASSIVE cheating by GMA. And HE-Lacson would have been president today with the death of FPJ.

IF ERAP had stood his ground, risking his life and never left Malacanang, he still have been president. But he left afraid he would be killed by the mob. A president who RUNS from a fight shouldnt be in office even for one second.

While i wish GMA would be ousted, i have to hand it to her: SHE DOES HAVE A LOT OF GUTS!

And yes, i voted for ROCO.

Avatar

benign0

September 24th, 2005 at 12:14 pm

Oust Gloria kayo nang oust Gloria diyan.

Sige nga? How exactly do you plan to oust her?

(1) Impeachment?

(2) Fiesta Revolution?

(3) Civil disobedience?

(4) Outright sedition?

Sige nga, tignan natin kung ano ang magagawa niyo diyan bukod sa pag-sigaw ng “oust Gloria” o “time to act” o “the time is now”

Sige nga?

In just a matter of months we’ve seen all four of the above fizzle out in the usual Pinoy style manner of the way things fizzle out.

ha ha! 😀

I think Pinoys had already made history from July to September of this year which I chronicle with my superb in-your-face analysis here:

http://www.getrealphilippines.com/admin/whatsnew.html

After all that, all we have to show for is one simple truism:

Pinoys cannot VOTE right AND ON TOP OF THAT cannot even impeach, revolt, disobey, and subvert right.

Pathetic to say the least.

ha ha! 😀

Avatar

agol_78

September 24th, 2005 at 12:52 pm

wag nyo pansinin si benignO, kulang sa pansin yan. american idol na phycologist na sira ulo

Avatar

INSIDE PCIJ: Stories behind our stories » Arroyo's wrath?

September 24th, 2005 at 1:35 pm

[…] Suspicious are the recently announced termination of the services of Mike Luz as education undersecretary and the anticipated decision next week on the Department of Agrarian Reform’s (DAR) findings on the case of Hacienda Luisita owned by the family of former president Corazon "Cory" Aquino. Mrs. Aquino has repeatedly called on Arroyo to step down. […]

Avatar

EEE

September 24th, 2005 at 1:51 pm

What do we expect? Nabuking sila e…. GMA administration doesn’t need uncooperative employee. Dapat bow lang sila ng bow para di sila mawalan ng work….kasi naman ayaw mag yes ma’am ayan tuloy nasibak. Ay naku! this country is going to the dogs…. Kawawa naman tayo.

Avatar

GANDALF

September 24th, 2005 at 4:11 pm

“Buking” is the term. Kaya magulo tayo ngayon.

Avatar

GANDALF

September 24th, 2005 at 4:47 pm

Tama si benigno on certain parts but his attempt to change how things are running is a futile one. What we are right now is a result of our culture and how it evolved from the early 1800s. A drastic change on things perceived to be wrong and which is a result of any culture evolution is something next to the impossible. Kaya benigno accept mo na lang kung ano tayong mga pinoy at dahil kasama ka din doon at kung ano ang kinahahantungan mo ngayon ay dahil resulta yan ng iyong culturang pinagdaanan. Kung paano tumatakbo ang pulitika dito, dahil din yan sa kultura natin. Kultura na kahit kailanman walang kasalanan ang mga pinoy. Kahit sinong lider ang ilagay niyo diyan, hindi niya mababago ang takbo ng buhay dito dahil sa kultura na kanyang kinagisnan.

Avatar

camille

September 24th, 2005 at 4:51 pm

Miguel Luz brought it upon himself. He maliciously implied that there’s an anomaly to the checks for the scholarship when there really isn’t. It’s not unusual for government to issue postdated checks. Teachers have long been receiving postdated paychecks from the DepEd. The checks were postdated probably because schools do not require students to pay a full year’s tuition fee all at once. Tuition fees can be given in installments.

News about Miguel Luz’ corrupt ways at the department may have prompted Malacanang to sack him. Besides his audacious lie.

Peace to all!

Avatar

twisted_brows

September 24th, 2005 at 7:04 pm

IT IS DE FACTO MARTIAL RULE! A PROSTITUTED PRESIDENCY NEEDS AN IRON FIST TO INSIST LEGITIMACY. HOW LONG WILL THIS LASTS?

Avatar

twisted_brows

September 24th, 2005 at 7:06 pm

EWAN KO SA IYO CAMILLE. MASYADO MO NAMAN NANG HINIHIMOD ANG MABAHONG TAE NI GMA SA KANYANG PUWET!

IT IS DE FACTO MARTIAL RULE! A PROSTITUTED PRESIDENCY NEEDS AN IRON FIST TO INSIST LEGITIMACY. HOW LONG WILL THIS LASTS?

Avatar

twisted_brows

September 24th, 2005 at 7:24 pm

BENIGNO, AKO REBOLUSYON. PERO HABANG WALA PA YON, ALL OF THE CHOICES THAT YOU LISTED SHOULD BE ENTERTAINED. THE POINT IS, WE HAD ENOUGH.

Avatar

nene

September 24th, 2005 at 7:38 pm

Mike Luz is not as clean as you think you PCIJ staff will have to balance your report. A visit to the ombusdman office in Agham road will lead you to the numerous complaints filed against Luz. A visit too the CSC-NCR will lead you to the complaint, of Luz manipulating the promotion system in the newly -created procurement service division to put it in his favored employees from outside. Because he thinks regular depEd employees are all corrupt. And you wonder why this guy loves the procurement division because that is where the money is. (DepED being the agency that gets the biggest chunk of the budget). He even blatantly stated in a memo that he is enjoying his stay at DepED so much that is why he resigned from AIM, DepED people hate him. This guy procures supplies without canvass, already ordering the supplies, e.g. t-shirts, then handing the order of payment to the property division for that division to complete the documentation when in fact there was no canvass conducted. And gets consulting services like the locsin architects without passing through a bidding and getting an advertising firm JEscom (if I am not mistaken) to promote textbook count 3 without it passing through the bidding. why does he do that? your guess is as good as mine. Looks and acts can be deceiving.

Avatar

INSIDE PCIJ: Stories behind our stories » Palace can’t fire DepEd undersecretary — CSC

September 24th, 2005 at 7:57 pm

[…] PRESIDENT Arroyo cannot sack Juan Miguel Luz as education undersecretary because he is a career executive service officer (CESO) and holds a regular item in the government plantilla. […]

Avatar

fencesitter

September 24th, 2005 at 7:57 pm

well if that is the case where is PAGC that harrassed roco during his term at the deped. where are the alinios now of deped who had been very vocal against roco because according to them roco was corrupt by allowing his wife to use the deped driver and by printing posters. bakit wala man lang ingay sa deped about corruption. mga hipocrito?

Avatar

dakdakero

September 24th, 2005 at 9:01 pm

Nene, if this insinuations are true about Luz, then there is no reason for us to make this a hot issue. Mas lalo pa nga tayong magsaya kasi nakunan ng isang taong corrupt ang Deped. Problema nga lang baka ang ipapalit masilaw rin sa pera, lam nyo na mainit ang procurement division. Anyways, hindi naman sinabi na pagreresignin. Pagkakalam ko, i-reasign lang.

Avatar

Frustrated OFW

September 24th, 2005 at 11:07 pm

I agree with what Ring said: time is running out for this government..Let the change begin…Time to act..Time is now… But why few people join these rallies/demos? Are they afraid or what? I think it’s only talk. I am so frustrated that I want to cry when I read the news and yet I can’t do anything because I’m far from home working in the difficult Middle East helping this corrupt government with my remittances. When I went on short leave recently I’ve been waiting for some rallies to join, but none happened. I hope those who are so frustrated should act now and no more talk. Thank you all.

Avatar

primo

September 24th, 2005 at 11:56 pm

luz refused to sign kasi madagdagan kaso nya sa ombudsman.. tama ka nene..

Avatar

primo

September 25th, 2005 at 12:01 am

i still would go for “Fiesta Revolution” brand na natin yan… wala pang sakitan… kaya GMA LAYAS dyan!!

Avatar

dakdakero

September 25th, 2005 at 12:19 am

‘ But why few people join these rallies/demos?,’ Frustrated OFW asked.
———-

For the simple reason. People are burnt out. Exhausted kung baga.
How many rallies and demos we’ve had since we are liberated from Marcos clout? Countless. Yet, there is only little change. We are still the same third world country doing the same rally’s and demo’s against presidents.

To add, there is also a psychological explanation to this. People have a lot of outlets to curb frustrations. We have this blog and other medium to say anything against the government. Kasi pag repressed ang tao, tendency nito sasabog na parang volcano. Yon ang nangyari kay Marcos noon. Sa sobrang higpit nya stalling the freedom of expression, ang mga tao nag-alboroto. Like raiding Radio Veritas station( A known anti Marcos Station). Nayari tuloy sya sa People Power.

Ngayon naman, (obserbasyon ko lang ha!) habang dumadami tayo dito sa blog, kumonti naman ang mga tao sa kalye. Last Wednesdays rally, hindi sumipot ang mga big time anti-GMA proponents na si Cory, Si Susan, at iba pa. Siguro, di natin alam, baka emotions nila are rechanneled at that particular moment. Take away this blog and other medium of expressions, di ba susugod lahat ng tao who have no emotional outlets.

Typical example is with the people who wants to commit suicide. Study shows that 90% of people who talks about commiting it, do not really carry the act. Reason for this is that they have already expressed their emotions verbally.

Isa lang ang paraan para magtagumpay ang People Power 3. Pandakekok should repressed all newspapers, radio stations, TV stations and blog sites who are against her. Yon lang mga parekoy!

Avatar

Tsquare

September 25th, 2005 at 12:29 am

Nene,

I wouldn’t know about any of the other allegations in your comments. But of one matter i do know: It’s likely that Luz has saved DepEd, and therefore the government , a hefty sum in getting the consulting services of Locsin architects, since they have provided these services pro bono and without fee, commission, purchase, or payment in any form. It’s a testament to Luz’s ability convince competent private sector firms to do their share of contributing time, effort, value, and expertise to the public interest at no cost to the people or government — all simply because it’s the right thing to do. I’d venture to guess that there was no bidding in this case because one typically does not bid out services for which there is no cost.

It shouldn’t come as a surprise if he says he enjoyed his stay at DepEd. If he is able to pull off initiatives like this as DepEd Usec-finance, I would imagine that saving government a few bucks is immensely satisfying. It also shouldn’t come as a surprise to know that he’d be hated by some in the department — these donated services are “opportunities lost” to those who view these initiatives as missed opportunities to influence a bid or make a tidy sum at government’s expense.

Avatar

dakdakero

September 25th, 2005 at 12:37 am

Another example: Sa mga lalaki kung pupunta tayo sa CR, maggawa ng milagro. Paglabas natin sa toilet,di ba parang na-relieved na yong tensions natin? It applies also sa sitwasyon natin dito ngayon. hehehe (sorry, for the censored statement). Our freedom of expression through this blog is not stalled thats why komonti ang tao sa kalye.

Avatar

Frustrated OFW

September 25th, 2005 at 12:39 am

Thanks, Dakdakero. But tell me, are these monstrous people in the government headed by the shameful president daw listening? I doubt it very much.

I have a request to pcij, pls. Would appreciate it very much if you can send this message to Mr. Bunye. I want to ask him if he can sleep soundly at night and a good one at that. Does his conscience bother him at all? When I see his face, he looks so kind and decent but the words that come out of his mouth is so worthless. Thank you all.

Avatar

dakdakero

September 25th, 2005 at 1:09 am

Yes, they are! The right word is not listening. Monitoring. Di natin alam, since PCIJ can be called one of the most famous visited blogs in the Philippines and the bloggers under the guise of pseudonames, we can never know all the political personalities are also here blogging. Parang nakinita ko nga nandito si Lacson, si Luli, Jinggoy, JV, ewan ko kay pandakekok. hehehe.

Avatar

schumey

September 25th, 2005 at 6:25 am

Camille

Question ko lang, kelan pa ba nagkaroon ng tuition fee ang public high school natin? Alam ko sa college meron but very minimal lang. Try to read the other reports on this site regarding the post-dated cheques so you will be enlightened. Walang tuition fee sa public schools.

Avatar

Toro

September 25th, 2005 at 7:10 am

Gandalf said:

“…Kung paano tumatakbo ang pulitika dito, dahil din yan sa kultura natin…. Kahit sinong lider ang ilagay niyo diyan, hindi niya mababago ang takbo ng buhay dito dahil sa kultura na kanyang kinagisnan.”

Maisingit ko lang sana ang aking munting kurokuro kaibigang Gandalf.

Sa aking palagay walang kinalaman ang kultura sa kasamaan ng pamamalakad ng pamahalaan. Sa umpisa’t umpisa ang mga namuno
sa ating bayan, pati na rin ang mga tao, ay lubos na matuwid ang isipan, matapat, may dignidad at mataas ang dangal. Ikaw na rin ang nagbigay puri sa mga pinuno natin noon pang panahong 1800. Ito’y kapanahunan ni Rizal at iba pa nating mga bayani. Batid mo rin marahil na masagana at matahimik ang Pilipinas hanggang dumating ang panahon na naging Pangulo si Ferdinand Marcos.

Ang ating kultura ay hindi kailanman magbabago. Ito’y dala natin hanggang ngayon. Ang kusang nagbago ay ang ating moralidad na sumisira sa ating dangal. Ito’y nagbago mula sapul ng naging Pangulo si Marcos. Dito nagmulang sumama ang pagkatao ng karamihang Pilipino. Ang nakitang kasamaan ng liderato ni Marcos gaya ng hindi makatwirang pakikitungo sa kapuwa, mga maling pagaasal sa sarili at pagnanasa sa yaman ng iba, hanggang sa pandaraya sa paglilingkod sa pamahalaan ay siyang naging huwaran ng mga tao. Ang lahat ng ito’y mas laganap ngayon. Ito’y hindi kultura na kinagistan ng mga Pilipino ngunit maaaring kinagistan mo kung ikaw ay nilalang sa mundo ng kapanahunan na ni Marcos. Ito’y kasamaang moral na pilit binabago ng nakararaming Pilipino na naghihimagsik ngayon at naghahangad maibalik ang dignidad ng tunay na maka-Dios na Pilipino. Sana’y isa ka na rin doon.

Datapwat kailangang magingat din ang tao sapagkat may mga huwad na nagsusulong para sa pagbabago ngunit may kubling hangarin upang itaguyod ang sariling hindi mabuting maka-taong hangarin.

Salamat Gandalf.

Avatar

camille

September 25th, 2005 at 7:41 am

schumey,

there are other school expenses besides tuition fees and they usually fall under miscellaneous fees. when a philanthropist takes on a scholar, books, supplies, transpo and daily allowances are also given. and not all scholars go to public high schools. some deserving ones go to private schools.

Avatar

twisted_brows

September 25th, 2005 at 11:52 am

camille, quid pro quo kasi yon. bayad kay diaz ang pondong yon. scholaship kuno. granted na pang-scholarship, bakit si diaz lang ang meron when everyone should be entitled? kamutin mo ang likod ko at ako'[y liliyad…

Avatar

twisted_brows

September 25th, 2005 at 11:55 am

primo, tama ka. pero kung marami na ngang kaso si luz, bakit hindi yon ang naging batayan ni gma? inalis siya dahil hindi siya marunong sumayaw, di ba?

Avatar

nene

September 25th, 2005 at 1:54 pm

are u sure tsquare, why don’t you check the request for payment unless it has been pulled out when the issue of sacking Luz exploded.

of course no bidding needed when the services are probono please don’t insult my intelligence.

Avatar

Tsquare

September 25th, 2005 at 4:44 pm

Nene,

I’m not in a position to check on any internal requests-for-payment records, although it sounds like you think there are such requests. But I am sure of no payments or professional fees charged from the side of the consultants.

Regarding the question, “…why does (did) he do that?” in reference to the absence of a bidding process, your comment earlier included the phrase “…your guess is as good as mine…”. So I ventured a guess, rhetorical as it may have sounded.

An old cliché goes something like this: “Speak not of what you do not know” — words to live by. And as I do not know you and have no way of knowing how intelligent (or not) you are, I could not have possibly meant my comments as an insult to you. No need for defensiveness, facetiousness, sarcasm or an overly thin skin here.

Avatar

nene

September 25th, 2005 at 7:45 pm

ok tsquare if that was not an insult, explanation accepted. but as a taxpayer it’s your right to verify what I stated, how else? by going to DepED. don’t forget to check on also on the campaigns and grey transaction when the past textbook counts were being promoted, check how this advertising firm was chosen. that is if you only want to. because taxpayers should know where their money goes, am doing more checking myself.

Avatar

jr_lad

September 25th, 2005 at 9:36 pm

fencesitter is right. if truly luz is corrupt, where is PAGC? kung yung pag-gamit lang ng wife ni roco ng deped driver and by printing posters matindi na ang ingay bakit dito kay luz lumabas lang na very corrupt dahil nabuko ang ginawang palusot ni gma about those checks for diaz? talagang maraming complaints kung may nasasagasaan. yung ombudsman, looks like harassment to me.
contradicting din etong sinasabi ni nene na obviously is working in deped (kasi pati mga internal requests-for-payment records alam niya), sinabi niya na may complaint daw kay luz sa CSC-NCR of manipulating the promotion system in the newly – created procurement service division to put it in his favored employees from outside. BECAUSE HE THINKS REGULAR depEd ARE ALL CORRUPT! sa yo galing yan ha? di ba may kasabihan birds of the same feathers flock together? very obvious ayaw ni luz sa mga eto. either na corrupt si luz or corrupt talaga ang mga regular employees. i choose to believe the latter. my belief is reinforced by dodie’s statement that luz is a man of integrity dahil nakapagtrabaho siya dito. kaya nga maraming nagalit kay roco eh dahil nilinis niya ang deped at kung hindi lang nathreatened si gma hindi niya sana sisiraan si roco at di sana umalis eto sa deped. speaking about siraan, diyan magaling si gma at mga bataan niya sa character assasination.
and about that consulting services that luz signed up, it seems nene wants to make us bloggers here believe that there is anomaly in the contract if not for Tsquare here attesting that is was pro-bono.

Avatar

koj

September 25th, 2005 at 10:11 pm

t-square, can you please eleborate further about the locsin architects contracts and what is it all about? and maybe how was it made pro-bono?

Avatar

jr_lad

September 25th, 2005 at 10:34 pm

a philantropist receiving public money through deped for him to provide scholarships to deserving poor high school students, some to study in private schools, at the middle of the school year, not anomalous or unusual? tama ba yung pagkaintindi ko?
eh bakit hindi na lang idiniretso bigay ng gobyerno sa mamamayan yang scholarship fund na yan. bakit pa padadaanin pa sa kung sinong poncio pilato ang pera ng bayan na para din lang pala sa mga mamamayan? ano bang kaulolan yan? At bakit kay diaz lang and w/o acountability sa part niya?
pakipaliwanag mo nga camille.

Avatar

camille

September 25th, 2005 at 11:28 pm

jr_lad,

diaz probably requested for funds for his scholarship program and since scholarship is part of GMA’s 10-pt agenda, it was granted. did you know that diaz requested DepEd to transmit funds to the respective schools?

what is so wrong with assigning DepEd as the implementing agency? DSWD was the implementing agency for the scholarship of several deserving students at Payatas and we didn’t hear any malicious insinuations from them.

Avatar

zorros

September 25th, 2005 at 11:34 pm

Diba si Cong. Diaz ang na accuse for sexual harassment by one of the starlet or hot babes???? Porbably ibang klaseng “Scholarship” program ito?

Avatar

baycas

September 26th, 2005 at 12:30 am

Frustrated OFW said,
September 24, 2005 @ 11:07 pm

… But why few people join these rallies/demos? Are they afraid or what? I think it’s only talk. I am so frustrated that I want to cry when I read the news and yet I can’t do anything because I’m far from home working in the difficult Middle East helping this corrupt government with my remittances. When I went on short leave recently I’ve been waiting for some rallies to join, but none happened. I hope those who are so frustrated should act now and no more talk. Thank you all.

—–

I like the article of Ms. Ma. Ceres P. Doyo on Malcolm Gladwell’s bestseller “Tipping Point: How Little Things Can Make a Big Difference.”
http://news.inq7.net/opinion/index.php?index=2&story_id=50253&col=82
http://news.inq7.net/opinion/index.php?index=2&story_id=50960&col=82

“TIPPING POINT” means a significant change in the balance from one tip to another. It proposes that social change shares three traits of epidemics: it is contagious, that little things can lead to large and unforeseen outcomes and that once the change takes hold it occurs suddenly. Gladwell summed up the “tipping point” into three rules:

1. The Law of the Few states that a few people – the right few people in each instance – have the power to influence a great number of others. The few’s currency is word-of-mouth.

Gladwell breaks these few into three categories, “Connectors,” those who know and are able to spread the word to a large number of others; “Mavens” who are looked to by others for advice; and “Salesmen,” who are capable of persuading others to take some action.

2. The Stickiness Factor. This rule suggests that something people hear or learn must be extra memorable; it must be “sticky.”

3. The Power of Context. It says the current social environment has to be ripe to embrace a specific principle or concept.

AS REGARDS our political quagmire: despite the ever-growing anti-Arroyo sentiments and surveys of Arroyo’s unpopularity, why isn’t it tipping to the anti-Arroyo’s side?

The Law of the Few.
The few (branded “destabilizers” by the government) are divided into four. First are the “few” who sowed disgust to the present Malacañang occupant but were once objects of disgust themselves during their heyday. They remained few in number as their cause would not spread due to their dubious character and their ardent desire to regain power. Second are the left-leaning forces. Obviously, no one in his right mind would get involved with them.

Next are the rightists who couldn’t muster their strength because most of them are now either “inactive” or are abroad sacrificing to earn their keep. These are the same people, together with some of the leftists, who installed GMA to power and are now re-thinking their position first before they move to oust her. Most of the “inactive” ones are the “segurista” types – they will only come out if the rallyists will swell to a People Power proportion (“segurista” much like the men in uniform who will only move to oust GMA when people will back them up, remembering their bitter lesson from the Oakwood miscalculation). Some of the “inactives” are also now apathetic to the situation, minding their own struggle through the hard times besetting the nation.

In addition, the majority of these rightists are sick and tired of corruption in government. They are now working or living overseas (contrary to what some people are saying that we have already a “People Power fatigue.” It’s just that there are no more People for the Power.). Last, and probably the least of the lot, are (pardon my saying) the “has-beens.” Few in number and certainly with unbelievable agenda.

The “few” couldn’t pull their acts together mainly because of their diverse personalities. Simply spreading the word is not going to work because the message is not clear. In fact, oneness of purpose (to get rid of GMA) is overcome by the multiple methods with which it is to be carried out (resign, impeach or oust). In short, words (not just a word) are being spread by the anti-Arroyos causing confusion to the general public. They also lack unity in coming up with a much better alternative. The question of a “viable option,” which the spin doctors of the government have inculcated in ordinary minds, works triumphantly for GMA. The unenthusiastic “seguristas” also contribute to the disunity – “Yes, we are not for GMA but give us first the assurance that there will be a deliverer in her place. Only then we will participate in the cause.”

Therefore, the Law of the Few would not apply to our setting for the “few” will remain “the divided few” even in months to come. “Mavens” we have…but our situation begs for the existence of the “connectors” and “salesmen.”

The Stickiness Factor.
Actually, the factor that will stick to one’s mind is the fact that GMA cheated her way to the presidency, destroying our valued institutions (Comelec, AFP and PNP, Namfrel, etc.) in the process. This can be gathered from the “Hello, Garci” Tapes. Hence, one will think that GMA is not the rightful occupant of the Office of the President and thus, she has no right to wield the power bestowed on it.

This rallying point, I believe, is the most detestable of all the “-gates” that came about the Arroyo government (juetenggate, gloriagate, lobbygate) because the sanctity of one’s vote is violated. GMA admitted it’s her voice in the tapes and her lawyer tongue-slipped that it’s Garcillano she was talking with in the tapes. A lot of the politicians cheated, even the bishops said so, but who got caught red-handed? It was the highest official in the land and certainly this should not be tolerated.

Unfortunately, it never entered the minds of the general public that each one of us is obliged to really take time to listen to the tapes. This is partly due to the Malacañang cover-up (Bunye’s blunder, Doble’s sudden turnaround, and conspiracy among NBI and ISAFP personnels), threat to prosecute those who are in possession of the tapes, “experts” questioning the authenticity of the tapes (one funny guy even retorted that it’s really her voice but she’s not the one actually talking), and twisting of the truth. Another reason is that the Gloriagate “lies” are being peddled by the equally dubious “destabilizers” themselves. Majority, I think, only rely on TV, radio and newspaper reports/commentaries (considering that they lack the equipment to listen to the tapes or are just too busy to bother with it). Then, you will only believe whom you choose to believe. Political leanings of an individual will come into play. (I wonder why the surveys don’t ask how many of us listened to the tapes. I wonder why the surveys don’t ask how many listened and believed its contents.)

This factor will never stick to our minds if we won’t listen to the tapes. We will never understand the gravity of GMA’s wrong deed if we won’t hear how she abetted a crime. We will never learn how repulsive her behavior was during the time she lusted for power. We will never know how ruthless she has become just to obtain her presidency. We will also never comprehend why she is strongly hanging on to power now, no matter what the cost is.

Sad to say, what sank into the minds of the general public – those who weren’t able to listen to the tapes and those who listened but nonetheless not convinced – is that the “Hello, Garci” recording is worthless evidence because it was illegally-sourced and it needs further authentication. And as events unfolded, the “mavens” and the “salesmen” in the guise of our bishops (note that they are not “connectors,” they are charismatic but they are spreading a message inimical to the cause) halted the furtherance of the cause. The truth was buried six feet under when they chose to participate in Gloria’s game of “Rule of Law.” The truth will continue to rot deeper underground as days, weeks, possibly years will pass, to the consternation of many but to the delight of the few officials in government.

The Power of Context.
The “great social change” is now pitted against “the great debate” on the Charter Change.

The tip to a social change without GMA at the nation’s helm almost happened in July 8. The concept is that GMA lied, cheated, and stole from the people; then adding insult to injury, covered them all up. This brings to the message, which is plain and simple, that she must let go of her power. That was the prevailing atmosphere then. But I don’t think it was ripe for the taking during that very, very long day because a lot of people were waiting for the CBCP statement (as if it was manna from heaven). The almost mature situation was inopportunely picked at that time. This gave the government time to regroup and assert its dominion over the populace despite growing anti-Arroyo feeling. The circumstance of extinguishing the power of the president by forcing her to resign died down (most especially when the CBCP took a lukewarm stance) and was replaced by the need for her to be impeached this time.

The situation wasn’t ripe for the taking and since the impeachment process was dismissed even before it prospered it continues to decay up to the present. Much to the dismay of everyone disagreeable to the Arroyo government, GMA still holds her power and she holds it very strongly now.

The “great social change” is now persistently waning whereas the “great debate” on Cha-Cha is in the offing. The current high in the public’s mind today is on charter change with the appointments of the expensive Arroyo Constitutional “Commission” (with emphasis on the quotation marks). This has supplanted the social environment then; the message was not embraced by the general public. As a consequence, the Context lost its Power instead of the Malacañang occupant.

HAVING SAID all that, I still would like to quote Mr. Ernie Adaya:

“Why isn’t it tipping? The answer is very simple: ‘Because (President Arroyo) is tipping’ and tipping generously for survival. In the Philippines, politicians, the influence peddlers, etc. are always on the lookout for the tipping point, because, like the waiters and waitresses in restaurants, they know that at the tipping point, the ‘tips’ will start flowing generously.

“Gladwell fails to realize that in the Philippines, there is a fourth rule of the Tipping Point, that is the Power of the ‘tip’ or the ‘TIPPING’ FACTOR.”

Avatar

schumey

September 26th, 2005 at 9:08 am

camille

I don’t like to engage you on your comments, please read the past reports about the cheques issued to Cong. Diaz so you can understand more thoroughly our comments.

Avatar

Tsquare

September 26th, 2005 at 12:00 pm

koj,

Luz had seen a project the architects had designed for a private foundation doing work in the area of literacy. Given the known shortage of good reading sources in many areas all over the country, he then convinced the architects — waiving any professional fees — to design a modest modular/standardized prototype distribution center that could be repeatedly built as adaptable renovations of older buildings or from scratch from which supplementary books, reading material, and electronic info could be organized, classified, and lent to schoolteachers to support the regular curriculum in schools nationwide. The centers were to be run by DepEd.

He also convinced the private literacy foundation to donate a large percentage of quality books for the centers. To make this a reality, he recruited the help of a major energy company to provide support and research tools for these facilities. These contributors to the project responded to Luz’s call wholeheartedly in recognition of the limited resources of the department, the importance of a literate, well-informed citizenry, and a strong sense of civic duty.

To date, only a few of these centers have been built, but those that have report good success. Hopefully, this project and other worthy ones like it survive their conceptualizer.

Avatar

mariatoo

September 26th, 2005 at 12:10 pm

si cong diaz nga yung may issue of groping/sexually harassing a a viva hotbabe member, ana leah javier.

he is also a magsaysay, of eulogio “amang” magsaysay fame.

he wanted the deped to give him personally the cash on the strength of a postdated check. personally ha. not from institution to institution. dadaan sa kamay niya.

Avatar

peacelabenpinay

September 26th, 2005 at 6:03 pm

Haaay naku…. nakakapagod na. Kahit anong panggigigil natin sa pag-papaalis kay pandak wala namang nangyayari. Parang naniniwala na ako kay Benign0 na kultura ang rootcause ng lahat ng ‘to.

Avatar

Frustrated OFW

September 26th, 2005 at 7:51 pm

Thanks Baycas. Your explanation is much appreciated, but I want to make it clear that I’m not one of those who installed gma. I voted (through absentee voting) another candidate and tried to encourage my friends to vote for the same candidate. Sad to say, they prefer Gloria and now I’m blaming all of you out there and here in the Middle East in putting her in Malacanang. By the way, all bloggers please read Conrado de Quiros article in today’s Inquirer. Perhaps those who are diehard gma loyalists will open their eyes and see the truth finally. Thank you all.

Avatar

tongue in, anew

September 27th, 2005 at 5:08 am

Very enlightening, Tsquare. With these accomplishments, and very creative ones at that, I guess we need more of the likes of Mike Luz who can craft cost-efficient solutions to help take every government office out of the shithole they are now in, thanks to the Mighty Mite in Malacañang, and provide the citizenry with quality public service it rightfully deserves.

I can only hope the gallant stand he has taken will be duplicated with equal fortitude by his colleagues in government who are similarly situated. With the other Luz sibling, Bill, contributing his share from the business front, private sector participation in government undertakings is a very potent force in restoring public trust in these dysfunctional government institutions that have been rendered financially and morally bankrupt by the Cheat Execu-thief.

Saddening as it may seem, the grain is separated from the chaff but only to be thrown away.

Avatar

koj

September 27th, 2005 at 5:52 am

Tsquare thanks for the info. it is indeed a good project and i share your hope that it would be carried on.

i heard from the news that luz would stay put with deped (maybe challenge thru legal means his transfer to wherever).

I did ask, mind you, because I’m skeptical with pro bono projects. Some are disguised as philanthropic activities only to cash-in to future projects, other undertakings or other favors in cash or in kind. it’s unusual or rather rare at this time to do pro bono. in normal cases, there’s always something in return.

Avatar

bilbuh

September 27th, 2005 at 8:53 am

koj,

i used to be wary of pro-bono arrangements too…as they say, nothing comes for free. but last july, I had the chance to attend a great event where some of the country’s top corporations rolled out some of the most innovative projects they were supporting in an effort to provide business solutions to social problems. Some businesses do well, and therefore they have the resources to do good…it’s called corporate social responsibility. That’s probably what groups like the Locsin Architectural firm are doing for this literacy project — giving back to the country in their own creative way. It’s a neat arrangement and the best part of it all is that millions of public school children will benefit.

Given his private and public sector service experience, Mike Luz has the strategic savvy to bring together the best of both worlds and make this result in highly innovative and creative programs and projects that benefit no one else but our otherwise ailing public school system.

Avatar

tikboy

September 27th, 2005 at 11:49 am

Mike Luz’s relief is nothing but a plain signal of Gloria Labandera’s revenge. Antay pa tayo ng konti baka si Fr. Robert Reyes ay pilitin ding mag-resign. :)

Avatar

Tsquare

September 27th, 2005 at 1:17 pm

koj,

…And that is the tragedy in this country, is it not? The kind of “transactional” practice you refer to — between those in government and their collusionists in the private sector — has become so widespread that it has rendered any legitimate and earnest efforts questionable and utterly unbelievable to the general public at large. Justifiably, ordinary pinoys have become so jaded and cynical that they can’t bring themselves to believe that anybody would actually heed JFK’s mantra “Ask not what your country can do for you, but what you can do for your country”. It is disheartening to note that the the forces in favor of this transactional practices constantly seem to be winning the cultural battle for legitimacy — and we continue to help the their cause and shoot ourselves in the foot by repeatedly voting these characters into public office once the floodgates of cash, favor, patronage, and fear-mongering are released come election time. It’s no wonder really that the best and brightest — and the most principled — stay away from government: Those who have the stomach to give it at go get crucified for trying to do the right thing or playing it straight. The folks with integrity are offered up on the sacrificial altar of the many who favor and legitimize this type of transactional governance. One doesn’t have to venture very far at all in recent years to see this. Tragically, it appears Luz is one of these casualties.

But bilbuh has it the nail on the head. Fortunately, there remain a stubborn few who insist on trying to make a difference. Among these are people and orgs who make a serious attempt at giving back and moving the referential goalposts. Businesses which are involved in initiatives for corporate social responsibility do precisely that. And it is to their credit that they spend much less of their time, resources, and expertise beating their chest about it or putting a “spin” on their work than channelling it toward the programs themselves. The eternal hope is that these efforts result in a more enlightened citizenry, capable of making better choices on a more level playing field within a meritocracy. Bottom line: the benefits can’t simply be measured in money or personal gain — it’s good for our culture, it’s good for the soul, it’s good for our countrymen, it’s good for governance, it’s good for business, and it’s good for your children.

Sounds like a pipedream? Well at this point, it is. The question really is, what will you do personally to make this a reality? As insurmountable as the objective seems, others have started it in small and seemingly unassuming ways — often to the derision of the cynics and so-called macro-realists. But that’s how great things get started. Change individually, think globally, act locally. Most critically: make choices based on your ideals, not your calculations.

Apologies for the sermon. Got a bit carried away there. Going back to your comment, pro bono stuff is indeed unusual and rare at this time in this country. But there is wisdom in not following the lemmings over the cliff — rare is good, and one may well sleep more soundly.

Avatar

INSIDE PCIJ: Stories behind our stories » Luz’s official statement

September 28th, 2005 at 12:56 am

[…] JUAN Miguel Luz is staying put as education undersecretary for finance and will bring a case before the Civil Service Commission if Malacanang insists on sacking him. […]

Avatar

kaskasero

September 28th, 2005 at 1:00 pm

scholarship funds is good for college students, but in high school, we knew that we have a free high school education in the philippines, in the case of cong diaz case regarding post dated checks, that financial process in unusual, it is violating the government accounting system, and beside there is no clear recipients of list of beneficiaries of that funds, how can deped liquidate if the division office made cash advances, could deped force cong diaz to liquidate. im just confuse really

Avatar

kaskasero

September 28th, 2005 at 3:32 pm

for all bloggers:
roco lessen corruptions in deped,deped employees particularly those who received service fee from lending institutions was angry to roco because he decided to stop receiving the said money instead he do some sharing of funds to all regions thru provident fund so that teachers can avail a loan at the lowest interest rate of 6% as what central office employees enjoying. because of that series of rallies held by employees when they see and got some evidence of little anomalies done by roco like using his driver, printing of posters…………tobecontinue

Avatar

INSIDE PCIJ: Stories behind our stories » Luz sues Malacañang

October 14th, 2005 at 2:41 pm

[…] Luz received his notice of transfer to the Labor department on October 4, 2005. He was fired as undersecretary on September 13, 2005 with a letter from Ermita thanking him for his services as undersecretary.   […]

Avatar

INSIDE PCIJ: Stories behind our stories » CSC backs Palace on Mike Luz’s transfer to DOLE

February 4th, 2006 at 9:31 pm

[…] Malacanang fired Luz on Sept. 13, two days after the PCIJ released a report that the Department of Education (DepEd) refused to accept three postdated checks (P15 million in all) the Palace had issued for the scholarship program of Zambales Rep. Antonio Diaz, saying this violated auditing rules and accounting procedure.  […]

Avatar

INSIDE PCIJ: Stories behind our stories » Mike Luz asks CSC to reconsider ruling

April 1st, 2006 at 12:40 pm

[…] Malacanang sacked Luz on Sept. 13 after he refused to accept three postdated checks (P15 million in all) the Palace had issued for the scholarship program of Zambales Rep. Antonio Diaz. DepEd said this violated auditing rules and accounting procedure. […]

Avatar

INSIDE PCIJ: Stories behind our stories » Mike Luz quits DepEd

April 22nd, 2006 at 8:31 pm

[…] Luz resigned nearly seven months after Malacanang sacked him from the Department of Education and ordered his transfer to the Department of Labor and Employment over his refusal to honor postdated checks the President’s Social Fund had issued to DepEd to fund the scholarship program of Zambales representative Antonio Diaz. […]

Avatar

INSIDE PCIJ: Stories behind our stories » Bureaucrats punished for accusing the Palace of disrespect for the civil service

May 8th, 2006 at 7:48 pm

[…] It cited the unjust termination of Education Undersecretary Juan Miguel Luz and former Pag-IBIG Fund president and chief executive officer Manuel Crisostomo, both career bureaucrats, and the appointment of non-civil service eligible officials. These, the CESB said “have resulted in growing apprehension and demoralization” in the civil service and threatened to “further erode the institutional foundations of a professional bureaucracy.” […]

Avatar

INSIDE PCIJ: Stories behind our stories » Mike Luz hits Arroyo’s low regard for civil service

May 11th, 2006 at 9:48 pm

[…] The Palace, through Ermita, at first sacked Luz, sending him a curt “thank-you” letter after he refused to honor three postdated checks issued by the President’s Social Fund. Ermita later ordered Luz’s transfer to the Department of Labor and Employment. […]

Avatar

stepping on poop. » Lamb to the slaughter.

July 1st, 2006 at 9:18 pm

[…] We Pinoys have a tendency to slaughter those who dare to speak truth to power, and while Borra may have been lucky to escape the bullets and bombs reserved for his kind, only Congress will show if his lucky streak holds. […]

Comment Form