July 25, 2005 · Posted in: General, In the News

The unmaking of the President

arroyo-sorry.jpgON the occasion of the State of the Nation Address (SONA) of Pres. Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo today, we are posting on our website the overview article of the i Report special issue, "The Unmaking of the President." Written by Sheila Coronel, the article describes how Arroyo, now hounded by mounting resignation calls and an impeachment case, is only reaping the consequences of the damage she has done on the electoral system and key institutions, the Commission on Elections, the military and the police, among them.

Arroyo’s actions, Coronel writes, can only be explained as those of a president who is insecure about her mandate and the affections of her people. She came to power in 2001 when Joseph Estrada was ousted only because she was his constitutional successor. Those who voted for her in 2004 did so mainly because she was perceived as the "lesser evil," not a principled choice.  

As a result, the article points out,  Pres. Arroyo’s inherent insecurity and instincts for survival have overwhelmed her sense of institutions. "She has put her own partisan political interests over the long-term development of the institutions of government. The scandal over The Tapes shows the ‘pitfalls of this approach: rather than bolstering her rule, the weakened institutions only further heightened her vulnerability."

Read on at pcij.org

28 Responses to The unmaking of the President

Avatar

benign0

July 25th, 2005 at 12:16 pm

“She has put her own partisan political interests over the long-term development of the institutions of government.”

Why zero in on the President? Doesn’t this observation apply not just to most Pinoy politicians today but also to most Pinoy politicians over the last 50 years? All of a sudden priority on politics over “long term development of institutions” suddenly becomes an issue.

How convenient.

You people fail to mention that this issue has BEEN an issue of Philippine society for the last five decades now. You talk as if it is something that BECAME an issue under the present administration.

No wonder Pinoy society is so rally-happy. It’s because people who exert so much influence are so into the business of removing what little perspective our ignorant society is already left with.

When you highlight the fact of our country’s failure to oversee the “long-term development of the institutions of government”, do you do so to imply a solution to address this issue itself, or do you do so to simply further the partisanism that already paralyses Philippine society?

Sure GMA cheated and needs to be impeached. But don’t make it look like SHE ALONE is responsible for the weakness and ineptness of our government institutions. THAT is something that Pinoys need to come to terms with whenever they stare into the mirror.

http://www.getrealphilippines.com

Avatar

benign0

July 25th, 2005 at 12:22 pm

Check out this excerpt from a Korea Times article:

“A recent opinion poll conducted by a reputable survey institute revealed how fed-up the people are with being sent to the streets by political agitators. When the Social Weather Stations (SWS) published its findings, the local media focused on the falling trust ratings of the president. Equally newsworthy I found the result that only two individuals out of more than 500 respondents opted for “people power.”

Refer to the full article here:
http://times.hankooki.com/lpage/opinion/200507/kt2005072216291354280.htm

If you inciters of political unrest haven’t gotten it thru your thick heads yet, most Pinoys have already tired of what now amounts to nothing more than noise.

We have so succeeded in perverting not only Edsa “revolutions” but also democracy itself. And I quote an excerpt from (ahem) a previous article of Yours Truly to elaborate:

“It is ironic that we self-righteously fancy ourselves the “victims” of foreign perverts when we ourselves have so effectively perverted many of the noble ideas of the “imperialist” powers. While other Asian societies have built on ideas adopted from the West, we applied them straight out of the box only to undermine them later; true to the form of our uniquely Pinoy passive-aggressive approach to excercising personal liberties.”

Read the full article here:
http://www.geocities.com/benign0/agr-disagr/10-5-perverted.html

Avatar

penpenpen88

July 25th, 2005 at 12:33 pm

Sure GMA cheated and needs to be impeached. But don’t make it look like SHE ALONE is responsible for the weakness and ineptness of our government institutions.

-I wholeheartedly agree.. id say haul all those past presidents past governors warlords jueteng lords and what have you, to court and make them accountable for past lapses in judgement. But let’s start with gloria pwede ba then ramos??-

Avatar

usda_gradeameat

July 25th, 2005 at 1:02 pm

tong isa dito..lahat na lang ng sinulat ng PCIJ e kontra…balik naman ng balik at basa ng basa ng mga artikulo dito….nanggagamit pa ng website ng me website para kumita…typical na typical ng amo nya….

cmon “get real” buddy! 😀

-MANINDIGAN SA KATOTOHANAN!

Avatar

eyesWIDEopen

July 25th, 2005 at 1:07 pm

hahahahha. nako. wag na kc siya pansinin. kc habang pinapansin lalong nanggagaliiti sa paggamit ng kanyang aircon! :)

Avatar

gangster_roger

July 25th, 2005 at 2:02 pm

why not start with lacson? then we redo erap all over again. shall we include cory too?

Avatar

gangster_roger

July 25th, 2005 at 2:06 pm

Root of all evil Gloria? Who agrees? When Gloria goes evil is gone too?

Tsk tsk…

We have a bright future!

Avatar

xanana

July 25th, 2005 at 2:21 pm

Lagi tayong ginagawang gago nito si benign0… sa totoo lang siya itong gago!! gusto lang kumita kaya ini-spam ang mga blogs at forum – (kaya na banned sa PEx).

Para matapos na ang pagii-spam nitong lokong to..

i click natin nang 1000 times yung kanyang “ads by google” para ma kick out din siya sa adsense program! para matapos na delihensiya niya.

Avatar

usda_gradeameat

July 25th, 2005 at 2:30 pm

LOL….wannabe PCIJ…..hahahahahahahaha …to namang PCIJ nagpapagamit…wag nyong payagang gawing classified ads tong blog site..buti sana kung me cut kayo sa kinikita nyan

get real buddy!

-MANINDIGAN SA KATOTOHANAN!

Avatar

usda_gradeameat

July 25th, 2005 at 2:34 pm

me pa article article pang nalalaman…e sya lang naman at sampu ng mga kaibigan nya ang nagbabasa…..

BWAHAHAHAHAHAH

MANINDIGAN SA KATOTOHANAN…….COM hahahahaha!

Avatar

benign0

July 25th, 2005 at 2:35 pm

Sino ang totoong gago, ang nagpa-gago o ang nang-gago?

For that matter, Whose fault is it that these politicians are using the country as their personal playgrounds? Why do we allow the rich to play on water-guzzling golf courses while the poor line up for their bucket-a-day ration?

Why are foreigners and descendants of foreign masters given preferential treatment over local indios?

Maybe it’s because we’d rather make jokes, organise rallies and throw pebbles at ivory towers to address these issues instead of hunkering down and building a true nation with solid foundations from the bottom up.

Avatar

jonathan

July 25th, 2005 at 3:26 pm

Let me give my two-cents on this article:
The article states that GMA is reaping the consequences of the damage that she has done to the military institution. How? The article mentioned the use of officers of the military to commit electoral fraud as ‘cited’ in the so-called Garci tapes. The article went on to further cite the ISAPF as an example of how a military agency was used to keep tab on her opponents. Let me start with the ISAPF theory. If GMA was in real “control” of ISAPF, she sure showed a sloppy job for not knowing that they have tapes on her conversing with Garci. If I was her, I would have destroyed those tapes from the very beginning and not let things develop into this mess. Wouldn’t it be more logical to say that although she has control on who to appoint at ISAPF, she doesn’t really have control on what ISAPF does? Second, on the ‘damaged’ military? Hello!! One coup against Marcos, seven coups against Cory, and the Oakwood Mutiny against Gloria: They are all crying reforms in the Military. The military has long been a damaged institution before Gloria. During the years following Edsa 2, Gloria courted the military not as a matter of choice, but as a matter of survival. The military knew that she came into power riding on their shoulders. That is why she needed the election to validate her rule and with popular mandate can very well reform the military. In fact we have seen this with the filing of charges and relief of commands of Gen Garcia and other generals, the move by Gen Abu to do away with the voucher system which is another source of graft, among others. That elements of the military have been used to perform jobs favorable to certain politicians is not news in the Philippines. Heck, they’re probably as old as our Republic. Actually, if the tapes were to be believed, the military is an equal opportunity practitioner because some generals are also mentioned as ‘sympathetic’ to FPJ.

Avatar

Sheila Coronel

July 25th, 2005 at 3:33 pm

The PCIJ has written entire books about the Philippine political class.The problem, as we wrote in The Rulemakers, dates back 100 years, rather than 50. We by no means blame the President solely for the deterioration of institutions. But we cannot go back to 100 years of Philippine history every time we write an article.

Avatar

Sheila Coronel

July 25th, 2005 at 3:43 pm

It would be naive to say that the politicization of the military began with President Arroyo. What the article tried to say, if it is read carefully, is that Mrs. Arroyo has played favorites with generals and dangled patronage to win the loyalty of the military, and she is now reaping the consequences of that. Disgruntled and out-of-favor military officers are far from happy with her presidency. In addition, such politicking has resulted in a loss of respect among the military rank and file for the Office of the President and the military top brass. Why else are we hearing all this noises about a coup? In particular, the politicization of the ISAFP creates an environment where the leadership of military intelligence loses its hold over the loyalty of its men, creating the conditions for a mere sergeant like T/Sgt Vidal Doble to consider the once-unimaginable: peddling information to the opposition.

Avatar

P.N. Abinales

July 25th, 2005 at 4:23 pm

Hi Sheila and Jonathan: just one point that needs pondering too. That there are people inside the military crying for reforms is true. But the ability to push for this reforms via extra-parliamentary means (a coup) is also almost an impossibility. Not only because GMA has successfully pitted senior officers against each other, but also because the folks who had done it in the past are now divided. RAM virtually ceased to exist once Gringo, Red Kapunan and others decided to run for political office; YOU dissipitated after Diosdado Valeroso and Danny Lim reintegrated themselves. None of these “older generation” of golpistas have ties with the Oakwood generation (save Gringo; but then Gringo is not RAM). So without that unity, nothing serious will happen in terms of the military. The wiretaps can destroy reputations and weaken politicians, but the are also petty undertakings, small-arms fire — as it were — and do not have the transformative impact as the coup.

Avatar

Raymond

July 26th, 2005 at 12:30 am

If the government as you so accurately describe is a disaster waiting to happen because of weakened institutions, is there any hope that things will ever change for the better regardless of who the president is?

I get reminded, in this regard, of that article James Fallows of Atlantic magazine wrote in 1987 about the Philippines being a sick society with a damaged culture. Despite most of us vociferously objecting to his criticisms, he was prescient in his observations then.

If we were to compare our country with a patient, the prognosis would be that of a terminally ill man. Since we have failed with our own resuscitative measures, is it time maybe to call in a consultation, maybe from the outside?

Our first Commonwealth president, Manuel L. Quezon, must be turning over in his grave to find out that his wish – a goernment run like hell by Filipinos – has come to pass.

Avatar

RUDYpilay

July 26th, 2005 at 11:22 am

Sino ang pipiliin ninyo?

A. Yung nagliligpit ng mga kidnapper at holdaper upang hindi na sila umulit ulit?

B. Yung harap-harapan na nagsisinungaling at dinudukutan ang bulsa ng naghihikahos na taong bayan, at dinadaya pa ito sa botohan?

Avatar

lovexneverxdies

July 26th, 2005 at 12:39 pm

Only 43 congressmen (out of 74 needed) voted for GMA’s impeachment? The CBCP and business groups are not calling for her to step down? Anong pa bang hinihintay natin? Was EDSA 2 merely a petty revolution by the petit-bourgeois?

It’s disgusting how we seem to be turning the other way.

Avatar

d_entrep

July 26th, 2005 at 4:34 pm

lovexnevrdies:

correct now you’re getting the picture of reality
were all taken by those petit-bourgeois,those text generation
were all fooled by these few people.their hate campaign so great
that even in classrooms they will tell their students that Erap is like this,
like that etc…My question right now.Is the couples for christ doing something,are those catholic schools,and private schools teaching
or telling them student that La Gloria is like this.why dont they invite their
students to attend those rally,and those employers give them half day pay if they would join the cause.Its quite IRONIC when we are fighting for the real truth no one is brave enough to stand.
what we are teaching to our children right now is its ok to cheat
just say SORRY afterwards.

Avatar

d_entrep

July 26th, 2005 at 4:52 pm

Hey Raymond:

Our first Commonwealth president, Manuel L. Quezon, must be turning over in his grave to find out that his wish – a government run like hell by Filipinos – has come to pass.

a government run like hell by Filipinos –
than a heeven by the Americans,-pls correct me if m am wrong

maybe in these current times,I would rather have an American…

Avatar

alb3ar

July 26th, 2005 at 8:53 pm

When Quezon was in Washington DC, they wined him and dined him and won him over: he sought a Commonwealth government with eventual “independence” ( although the PI is still dependent on the US economy up till present. Truly the Philippines now reaps what he sowed. In my opinion, they really wanted the Philippines not as a territory but as an eventual trade partner. Quezon would have had a juicy position being very very close to Gen. Mac Arthur who was head of the US Armed Forces in the Far East.

Not that the American system is perfect but if run by the Americans, a lot of hush hush politics would not have happened in the Philippines.

Avatar

initdisyerto

July 26th, 2005 at 11:58 pm

nagtiwala pa kasi kay victor curpoz… di ba sa article of war pagkumabila kana overthebakod ika nga firing squad ka. hindi eh pinalaki pa. nilampasan pa ng ranggo yaong mga naging loyal sa AFP. ang masama pa sa isang napakasensitive pang pwesto, ang ISAFP.

he he he outrageous talaga!

wala daw pueding pamalit kay gloria arroyo dahil sa taas ng pinagaralan… kaya lang nakalimutan yata ang law of supply and demand.

ang brazil isa ring maunlad na bansa… pinamunuan ng isang 8th grader lang… at ang ating kalayaan, galing lang sa isang bodegero ng tundo, BUDEGERO GAT ANDRES BONIFACIO!

Avatar

ParengPepe

July 27th, 2005 at 2:06 am

A man died and went to heaven. As he stood in front of St.Peter at the
Pearly Gates, he saw a huge wall of clocks behind him. He asked, “What
are all those clocks?” St. Peter answered, “Those are Lie-Clocks.

Everyone on Earth has a Lie-Clock. Every time you lie, the hands on your
clock will move.” “Oh,” said the man, “Whose clock is that?” “That’s Mother Teresa’s. The hands have never moved, indicating that she never told a lie.”

“Incredible,” said the man. And whose clock is that one?” St. Peter
responded, “That’s Abraham Lincoln’s clock. The hands have moved twice,telling us that Abe told only two lies in his
entire life.”

“Where’s Gloria Macapagal Arroyo’s clock?” asked the man. The Philippine President’s clock is in my office. I’m using it as a CEILING FAN.”

Avatar

koj

July 27th, 2005 at 3:36 am

sa totoo lng, pag gusto ko uplift ang spirit ko, nagbabasa na lng ako ng blogs dito…kasi sa dami ng desperado mas naapreciate ko sitwasyon…he he he…

pa-annex na lng kasi tayo sa amerika, kalimutan na natin sinabi ni quezon…palagay ko kung mag-plebisito mas maraming aayon dito…biruin mo makapunta at makapag work tayo ng walang visa sa ‘tate…pag tinamad (e marami naman talagang tamad) tayo mag work, pa welfare na lng, papunta-punta na lng tayo sa center para kumain, o di ba swabe? mix na rin natin breed natin sa kanila para blue eyes ang labas, naks!

jokes lang!

Avatar

RUDYpilay

July 27th, 2005 at 11:20 am

Dude, like what’s your point?

Avatar

korab

July 27th, 2005 at 11:36 am

oo nga pa-annex na lang tayo sa amerika…tapos papalitan na ng mga pinoy yung mga chikano na gumagawa ngtrabaho na ayaw gawin ng mga puti ( at itim)…hehehe

Avatar

RUDYpilay

July 27th, 2005 at 12:17 pm

Baka naman kailangan natin ng permiso ng mga Amerikano muna bago natin sabihin na kailangan maging parte tayo ng US. Kung may uunahin sila na i-annex sa kanila, di ba yung mga meksikano muna, dahil:

1. Tutal marami nang iligal na meksikano sa Amerika. Kung huhulihin o pauuwiin man ang lahat ng iligal sa Meksicano sa tate, magsasara ang karamihan sa restoran at kompanyang konstraksyon sa US.

2. Maraming pinuno ng pamahalaan sa US ang 2nd o 3rd generations mexicans. Isang halimbawa yung pumalit kay Ashcroft bilang Atty. General, di ba mexicano yon? E di mas marami ang impluwensya nila.

3. Si Bush ay kaibigan ni President Vicente Fox ng Mexico. Malapit sa puso niya ang mga mexicano, magmula pa noong gobernador siya ng Texas, na may malaking populasyon ng Mexicano, dahil ka border nga ng Texas ang Mexico. Sa katunayan nga, sa kasalukuyan ay tinetesting ni Bush ang tubig at pinapalaot ang idea ng amnesty para sa mga illegal. Tinitingnan niya muna ang opinyon ng mga mamamayan. Kaya nga ngayon, sa karamihan ng talk show sa Istate, maging radyo o tv, o maging Demokrat man o Republican ang host, illegal immigration ang pangkaraniwan na topic.

Kaya nga kung gugustuhin man ng merika na magkaroon ng bagong estado, natural lamang na Mexico ang uunahin. Huwag muna nating ipagsaksakan ang sarili natin, baka lang tayo mapahiya sa bandang huli. Ipagpalagay natin na gusto ng mas nakararami ang maging kano tayo, tatanggapin ba kaya tayo ng mga tunay na kano?

Avatar

ejam

August 8th, 2005 at 2:34 am

Hmmm. . . . .very interesting. E kung sa Japan na lang kaya? Actually, kung hindi dahil sa kano, baka Japanese na tayong lahat ngayon. Bakero!

Comment Form