September 28, 2005 · Posted in: In the News

GMA clips congressional powers

PRESIDENT Gloria Arroyo today issued Executive Order 464 clipping the powers of Congress to conduct hearings and to summon officials of the executive department to testify before congressional inquiries.

The order requires cabinet members, police and military generals, senior national security officials, and "such other officers as may be determined by the President" to first seek her approval before appearing before any inquiry of the Senate or the House of Representatives.  

The President invoked "the constitutional guarantees of the separation of  powers of the Executive, Legislative and Judicial branches of government" to justify her decree. She also cited Article VI Section 22 of the Constitution which allows cabinet members and other officials to testify at congressional hearings with the permission of the President.

The order was issued as two military officers appeared before the Senate Committee on National Defense which began hearings on the "Hello, Garci" scandal and allegations the President committed fraud  in the May 2004 elections. 

It also comes a week after National Security Adviser Norberto Gonzales faced a Senate inquiry on the issue surrounding the government contract with Washington-based law firm Venable LLP.

Read the full text of Executive Order 464 here.  

67 Responses to GMA clips congressional powers

Avatar

eyesWIDEopen

September 28th, 2005 at 4:55 pm

Isang EO mula sa pekeng pangulo.

Bakit natatakot ang mga militar sa kanya? bakit natin bigyan ng respeto ang EO na yan. Pekeng pangulo walang mandato.

HIndi totoo. Walang karapatang mag EO. bakit? bobo ba talaga tayo?

Avatar

agol_78

September 28th, 2005 at 5:00 pm

matali si GMA, ginagawa nya tayong bobo.

she will use all her powers as President d ba?

Avatar

lumpen

September 28th, 2005 at 5:35 pm

PGMA has a point in her EO, congress should really be able to respect the separation between the Executive and the legislature and understand that heads of executive departments, secretaries, are accountable to the president only.

My beef with the EO is that it is inconsistent with PGMA’s call for a constitutional redesign (in her words, to correct systemic defects in our political system). For a president who has espoused her advocacy for parliamentary government and who urged everyone to start the “great” constitutional debate, her true colors have just surfaced with this EO as it clearly indicates as least two things–her predilection to issue policy statements out of convenience without really understanding the repercussions of such statements and the maximal extent of operations of her cabal of legal consultants, public image experts, dirty and rough tricks experts, and control freaks as this group seems to be churning out everything in a huff—from propaganda materials (expensive tarpauline hallelujahs to the chief around the metropolis, countless praise releases), legal cases filed against opponents, walking papers given to obstructionist bureaucrats, and now, Executive Orders design to make executive appointive officials solely accountable to the Chief whose ass they have licked and whose egos have been constantly massaged by an increasingly captured President.

Avatar

indio_lawless

September 28th, 2005 at 5:39 pm

Grabe, nakaka-tokat naman yan kaya oka tokat na tokat!

Marshal-LOW na nga de facto wise :)

Alecks, if the time comes, paki-delete lahat ng IP adresseses na naka register dito sa site nyo ha.

Mahirap na mabartolina, walang blog dun eh :)

Avatar

gagay

September 28th, 2005 at 6:04 pm

pano lagi kasi syang binubuko ng mga tuta nya (Bunye, Defensor, Gonzales). ganyan talaga pang puro kasinungalingan at guilty, kahit anong klaseng pagtatakip sa baho, sisingaw at sisingaw din yan. ngayon patatahimikin nya mga gabinete nya, mas malaking gulo ang nagagawa ng nakakabinging katahimikan. look at pandak herself, remember ang tagal nyang nanahimik sa hello garci controversy, tingnan mo, biglang napa amin si loka.

habang tumatagal, binabaon lang ni gloria ang sarili nya sa kumunoy ng kontrobersya. is this what we have to bear until 2010???!

Avatar

LCsiao

September 28th, 2005 at 6:26 pm

lumpen,

Paano nagkaroon ng punto doon sa EO si Tianak? Kaya nga may 3 sanga ng gobyerno, para magsilbing “check and balance” sa isa’t isa.

And why should cabiner secy’s be answerable to the cheap executive only? Aren’t they more answerable to the people thru congressional oversight?

Avatar

hunghang

September 28th, 2005 at 6:40 pm

pandak is a it again. Matapos busalan ang mga ebidensya sa kongreso, pinakialamanan naman ngayon pati ang senado.

Wala bang magagawa ang ating senado na protektahan ang 2 officers na nagtestify sa senado today?

Avatar

INSIDE PCIJ: Stories behind our stories » U.P. legal and technical experts to attend Senate hearing on NorthRail project despite Arroyo order

September 28th, 2005 at 7:28 pm

[…] ON account of Executive Order No. 464 issued by Pres. Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo this afternoon, newly appointed U.P. College of Law Dean Salvador Carlota has instructed members of the U.P. Law Center not to attend tomorrow’s Senate hearing of the Committee of the Whole investigating the NorthRail project. […]

Avatar

shinobu

September 28th, 2005 at 7:36 pm

hmmn. i didn’t know the army was an independent and equal branch of the government. what is the logic of preventing army from reporting to senate, the elected representatives of us?

Avatar

concerned citizen

September 28th, 2005 at 7:49 pm

wala ng authority si arroyo mag eo. tingnan mo nga di na sya sinusunod. di na pinapansin mga order nya. kagaya kanina tinuloy pa rin ng dalawang officers magtestify sa senate hearing about wiretapping. bukas tuloy mga up profs & students sa hearing sa senado about north rail project. o ano pa silbe nya di na sya sinusunod. sabi ni almonte ganito rin daw ang nangyari ng panahon ni marcos. ibig bang sabihen babagsak din si arroyo gaya ni marcos? history repeats?

Avatar

nnk

September 28th, 2005 at 7:55 pm

Eo?! Hindi naman siya Presidente e.

Avatar

benign0

September 28th, 2005 at 9:25 pm

Ayan na mga kabayan. So all of a sudden, we suddenly cozy up to the concept that our beloved congressmen are “elected representatives of us”. All this after making hollow-headed calls to march to the streets and void the decision on GMA’s impeachment by these same “representatives”.

Now that the President is implementing efforts to weaken the very same Congress that we so reviled, bigla na lang we exhibit indignation against this action and stand behind this Congress.

Yet another irony as only the Philippines can produce.

Ano ba talaga?

Which makes the timing of the release of our brilliant SLIDE SHOW on Why Filipinos Should Get Real. Check it out here:

http://www.getrealphilippines.com/tour/slide01.html

Happy viewing! 😀

Avatar

LCsiao

September 28th, 2005 at 9:40 pm

Naku, BenignO, may pa-irony-irony ka pa.

Simple lang yan. At the end of the day, Doña Gloria is the most reviled amongst the current crop of politicians in the country today. Kung baga e, buwaya man ang tingin sa mga congressmen, Satanas na ang imahe ni Gloria sa sambayanan.

Avatar

jun31

September 28th, 2005 at 10:19 pm

Sa tinging ko, si Gloria Arroyo ay mas masahol pa kay Pres. Marcos dahil si Pres. Marcos tinatawag niya ang Martial Law as Martial Law si Gloria Arroyo ayaw pa nyang tawaging Martial Law ang kanyang mga ginagawa para di sya mahuli.

Hanggang ba dito sinungaling sya?! Eh, teka, bakit ko pa tinatanong yung, alam naman natin na sinungaling sya!

Avatar

jr_lad

September 28th, 2005 at 11:27 pm

Bengino,hindi naman lahat ng senador at congressmen hawak ni gloria. tuloy pa naman ang mga imbestigasyon ng mga diffrent committees sa mga anomalya ng gobyerno kaya dapat lang na kondenahin etong bagong EO ni gloria.

pansin ko dumadami na talaga ang problema ni gloria. nagsusulputan na. dami na siyang tauhan na di sumusunod sa kanya. wrong move after wrong moves pa ginagawa niya. pag komontra, tanggal. etong tinanggal aangal dahil illegal and politically motivated ang dahilan. lalabas sa media at magkakaroon ng symphaty sa tao. mas madami tuloy naglalabasan na baho ni gloria. kaya di niya na talaga nagagampanan ang trabaho niya bilang presidente at para mapalakad ng maayos ang gobyerno. nauubos na oras niya at ng mga bataan niya sa pagtatanggol ng sarili para di matanggal sa puwesto. wala pa akong nakitang presidenteng nagkaroon ng ganito kadaming problema. kahit sa time ata ni marcos hindi siya namroblema ng ganito. malamang di man siya mapatalsik ng tao, masiraan naman ng ulo dahil di na makatulog at makakain. :) so ang labas natanggal dahil mentaly incapacitated na si gloria. tingin ko lang ganon mangyayari. just a matter of time. :).
abangan…

Avatar

emer

September 28th, 2005 at 11:27 pm

korek kayo dyan talagang reyna ng kasamaan si gloria, kampon talaga ng kadiliman.nakakagigil na .

Avatar

tongue in, anew

September 29th, 2005 at 5:07 am

What’s next, immunity from charges in court of gov’t officials owing to the separation of powers clause? Whatever happened to the principle of checks and balance?

Tomorrow, after the UP Law Center members are done with their testimony in the Senate, they will join the other honorable public servants who are newly-unemployed, and for sure, they will be replaced by nominees of the Firm.

I would like to suggest that any journalist keeping tab of the recent pronouncements, orders, and policies of the present overstaying visitor in Malacañang to provide us a list of the same so that the moment this Cheat ExecuThief is removed, she will have to answer to the people for all her sins, venial and mortal. I don’t care if it happens tomorrow, next week, next year, or in 2010.

She won’t escape the inevitable.

Avatar

concerned citizen

September 29th, 2005 at 7:19 am

sinabi mo jr-lad. ang alam ko kahit daw noong kabataan ni arroyo ay may sarileng mundo daw ito. ayaw makinig at matigas ang ulo. matalino daw talaga. ganoon naman ang sobrang talino tingnan mo si miriam di ba sabi nila may tililing? sana habang maaga magliwanag isep ni arroyo. wala na syang patutunguhan. she can no longer govern our country dahil sa sandamakmak na problema. sana magising na sa katotohanan na ayaw na talaga sa kanya ng karamihan ng tao. ang hirap kasi nagbubulagbulagan. ayaw maniwala sa surveys. popolarity contest daw. so pls ginang arroyo. maawa ka sa sarile mo sayang naman ambition mo. nasira..

back to the issue, di ba may separation of powers ang excecutive, congress at judiciary? 3 equal branches? di sinunod ang rule of law. pwede check & balance. kaya pwede magimbestiga senate sa mga tao ng excecutive. bakit ayaw paimbestiga? kasi mapapahiya at lalabas baho ni mrs pidal. wala pang presidente na nag issue ng ganitong eo. only in the govt. of arroyo.

Avatar

deep_eyed

September 29th, 2005 at 8:21 am

kahit ano pa ang ibigay na EO ng “questionable president” eh wala naman pupuntahan. she can’t control everyone. sa mga pag-issue ng mga ganyang EO, i think yun din sisira sa kanya(mas lalo pa, kasi sira na sya).

Avatar

assumptionista

September 29th, 2005 at 9:07 am

There is a separtaion of the excecutive, congress and judiciary. It is there in our constitution so that there will be check and balances. By coming up with the EO she basically wants to be not in a democracy but an authoritarian government.

What is she hiding? If she is not hiding anything why is she preventing her officials to speak?

It goes to show that she is guilty of lying & cheating? and the sad thing is we are letting her get away with it, by not doing anything!

And to Benigno, how much are you getting paid? Just asking…. he…he…. I share mo naman sa amin…..mukha kasi malaki eh….. biro mo kahit anong gawin ni GMA ok lang sa iyo……

Avatar

vonpogi

September 29th, 2005 at 9:18 am

TO GENERAL GUDANI…………….
He is at least one general who refuses to obey an illegal order and was more than willing to show by example, what a good officer and gentleman should be. Now that takes courage.

Avatar

peacelabenpinay

September 29th, 2005 at 9:43 am

The EO is obviously unconstitutional. Legal experts should question it before the Supreme Court.

Avatar

benign0

September 29th, 2005 at 9:49 am

assumptionista said,
September 29, 2005 @ 9:07 am
======
And to Benigno, how much are you getting paid? Just asking…. he…he…. I share mo naman sa amin…..mukha kasi malaki eh….. biro mo kahit anong gawin ni GMA ok lang sa iyo……
======

What if I tell you I’m paid a sh1tload of money and jet-setting around the world using YOUR tax money. Maiinggit ka ba? 😉

Sarap nang naka-Mercedes lalo na pag naka-todo ang erkon.

ha ha! 😀

Avatar

assumptionista

September 29th, 2005 at 11:02 am

Benigno,

OH SO THAT IS WHY YOUR LIKE THAT !! I’m happy for you !!he..he…he…
At least your honest about it unlike your madam President !!
And anyway… SOMEONE JUST TEXTED….. and if I may quote him:

“Can’t wait to be with Benigno at the other side…I know he wants to be the president here but I have already reserved that slot for a small woman, but tell him that he is gonna be my SPOKESPERSON!! ” – Lucy ( also fondly called “taning”)

So enjoy the aircon of your mercedes….its going to be hot there….he……he…

Avatar

agol_78

September 29th, 2005 at 11:26 am

SI BENIGN0 kulang sa pansin, guguluhin nya lang ang blog na ito pag magcommwnt ka sa kanya. american idol yan sa phycologist na sira ulo

Avatar

benign0

September 29th, 2005 at 11:43 am

assumptionista said,
September 29, 2005 @ 11:02 am
======
Benigno,

OH SO THAT IS WHY YOUR LIKE THAT !! I’m happy for you !!he..he…he…
At least your honest about it unlike your madam President !!
And anyway… SOMEONE JUST TEXTED….. and if I may quote him:

“Can’t wait to be with Benigno at the other side…I know he wants to be the president here but I have already reserved that slot for a small woman, but tell him that he is gonna be my SPOKESPERSON!! ” – Lucy ( also fondly called “taning”)

So enjoy the aircon of your mercedes….its going to be hot there….he……he…
======

I certainly am enjoying it. How’s the weather from where you’re sitting. A bit sweaty under the arms? ha ha! 😀

Don’t worry, when I become president, I will aircondition all of Manila. Using your Tax money of course (with a bit of kickback from the contractor for good measure).

I’ll bet things will STILL be the same in our little islands nation by the time that happens.

ha ha! 😀

Avatar

Duck Vader

September 29th, 2005 at 12:10 pm

Which makes the timing of the release of our brilliant SLIDE SHOW on Why Filipinos Should Get Real. Check it out here:

http://www.getrealphilippines.com/tour/slide01.html

Happy viewing!

—————
Brilliant? Don’t oversell yourself, kid. At best, they’re groups of obvious observations; at worst, they’re flawed generalizations. Either way, they offer no real insight into what the real problems are and what need to be done. You give no reasons as to why those traits that you criticize so roundly came to be (assuming that your criticisms are correct). My guess is that you’ll say “culture.” So the question is, what creates or sustains this “culture”? You haven’t answered that question.

You speak in generalizations. But it’s easy to mouth motherhood statements. Formulating the proper policy interventions is much more difficult — and in that your brilliant slides are obviously lacking.

For instance, you say that we Filipinos are not as entrepreneurial as the Chinese. The question is why? Was there a genetic lottery that gave the Chinese entrepreneurial genes but not the Filipinos? Or was it some other factor, and what aspects of it created an entrepreneurial culture? Can we replicate the conditions? What are those conditions?

Pag nasagot mo yan di may naitulong ka sa debate, imbis na tawagin mo simply na culturally deficient ang Pinoy at superior ang Chinese di ba?

Avatar

Frustrated OFW

September 29th, 2005 at 12:39 pm

Good morning to all you bloggers. Read Conrado de Quiros’ article in today’s Inquirer and see how you feel about it. There are a few who speak their minds but the majority of the Filipino people are just plain unconcerned which is really frustrating. And to the bloggers here who are connected to Malacanang or even elected officials, shame on you and your families. You are to serve the people and not only those power hungry vermins in the government led by that usurper bogus president. Mahiya kayong lahat. And you BenignoO, whoever you are keep your mouth shut because the words that spew from your mouth are garbage. And to all the defenders of Arroyo, I hope you are all true to yourself and that you really believe in her and not being paid. SHAME ON YOU.

Avatar

fencesitter

September 29th, 2005 at 12:45 pm

This comment on Chinese being enterprenurial lot than any other race is lots of bull. How could they be when all businesses in China is owned and contolled by their government. The commercial accomplishment of Chinese in the philippines happened because they are already Filipinos not anymore Chinese.

Avatar

tikboy

September 29th, 2005 at 1:11 pm

kayo naman, pagbigyan niyo na si pandak. a few last EOs na lang naman niya yan e… hehehe

Avatar

benign0

September 29th, 2005 at 1:23 pm

Duck Vader said,
September 29, 2005 @ 12:10 pm
======
Brilliant? Don’t oversell yourself, kid. At best, they’re groups of obvious observations; at worst, they’re flawed generalizations. Either way, they offer no real insight into what the real problems are and what need to be done. You give no reasons as to why those traits that you criticize so roundly came to be (assuming that your criticisms are correct). My guess is that you’ll say “culture.” So the question is, what creates or sustains this “culture”? You haven’t answered that question.

You speak in generalizations. But it’s easy to mouth motherhood statements. Formulating the proper policy interventions is much more difficult — and in that your brilliant slides are obviously lacking.

For instance, you say that we Filipinos are not as entrepreneurial as the Chinese. The question is why? Was there a genetic lottery that gave the Chinese entrepreneurial genes but not the Filipinos? Or was it some other factor, and what aspects of it created an entrepreneurial culture? Can we replicate the conditions? What are those conditions?

Pag nasagot mo yan di may naitulong ka sa debate, imbis na tawagin mo simply na culturally deficient ang Pinoy at superior ang Chinese di ba?
======

Great questions tatang! 😀

As to the why part, I propose a theory of how this disparity in success and failure in this little parable here (that is of course if you have the time to read it):

http://www.getrealphilippines.com/solution/

Other authors such as Samuel Huntington and Jared Diamond also propose more comrehensive and more scholarly theories about how the disparity in commercial success between cultures came about.

On the other hand, one simple fact remains regardless of the WHY part — that we are what we are today — a society on the brink of failure, a chonic laggard, and subservient to commercially successful subcultures within our society. A situation shared by a country like Malaysia. The only difference is that they have the degree of introspection to recognise this situation in an official capacity as Mahathir himself articulates in his “Malay Dilemma” rantings here:

http://www.geocities.com/benign0/agr-disagr/17-1-newmalay.html

Kung baga, we can rack our brains and point fingers at every doodad to explain why we are what we are today, but it won’t change the fact that we are what we are, that we need to RECOGNISE this, and to build solutions based on what we have come to terms with as our national character.

Here’s an excerpt from some of Mahathir’s writings on this issue (from the article pointed to by the abvoe link):

====================
“When I wrote The Malay Dilemma in the late 60s, I had assumed that all the Malays lacked the opportunities to develop and become successful. They lacked opportunities for educating themselves, opportunities to earn enough to go into business, opportunities to train in the required vocation, opportunities to obtain the necessary funding, licences and premises. If these opportunities could be made available to them, then they would succeed. ……

…. But today, the attitude has changed. Getting scholarships and places in the universities at home and abroad is considered a matter of right and is not valued any more. Indeed, those who get these educational opportunities for some unknown reason seem to dislike the very people who created these opportunities. Worse still, they don’t seem to appreciate the opportunities that they get. They become more interested in other things, politics in particular, to the detriment of their studies. In business, the vast majority regarded the opportunities given them as something to be exploited for the quickest return. …… They learn nothing about business and become even less capable at doing business and earning an income from their activities. They become mere sleeping partners and at times not even that. Having sold, they no longer have anything to do with the business. They would go to the government for more licences, permits, shares, etc. …. ”
====================

Happy reading! 😀

Avatar

jr_lad

September 29th, 2005 at 3:26 pm

saw gloria on tv last night. laki na ng eyebags. very obvious di na talaga nakakatulog. lalo lang siyang namroblema sa EO na inissue niya. sa halip na solution sa problema niya nakadagdag lang lalo. pati kakampi niya sa congress komontra na rin. for how long can she hold on? sabi ko nga it’s a matter of time. malapit na talagang bumigay.

Avatar

LCsiao

September 29th, 2005 at 3:59 pm

Kaya nga pakapal nang pakapal ang mukha, este…make-up niya.

Avatar

tikboy

September 29th, 2005 at 5:04 pm

jr_lad,

kaya di nakakatulog ang presidente mo kasi iniisip pa niya kung sino ang di pa nabibigyan na doggy niya at kung saan pa siya kukuha ng ibibigay niya para di na kumahol ang mga ito. hindi siya namomroblema sa EO no? puwede naman siyang magpalusot ulit na lapse in judgement yun, di ba?

buti pa kasi si brenda nagsabing: i lied, hehehe. ang presidente niyo kelan kaya aamin? kahit damihan na niya ang “hehehe” para di na mahalata ang “i lied”. 😀

Avatar

penpenpen88

September 29th, 2005 at 5:32 pm

sabi nga nila… can’t correct a mistake by making another one folks.. that’s just not the way it should be done.. those who are advising the president and being paid with our taxpayers money… if you were in the tv series the apprentice.. donald trump will echo what were going to tell you know.. YOUR ALL FIRED!!!!!!

Avatar

riveradam_p

September 29th, 2005 at 7:43 pm

Can’t wait for the presscon of Ms. International with GMA in malacanang. Side by side Beauty and the Beast.

Avatar

schumey

September 29th, 2005 at 7:52 pm

Majority congressmen back the EO. Talagang rubberstamp congress na ito. I wouldn’t be surprised that we’ll all wake up one morning only to discover that martial law has bee declared and approved by congress. Yehey! Instant Cha-Cha and FVR, JDV, GMA all stay in power. So sleep tight my dear kababayans and pray that a tsunami from the Pasig River swallows Malacanang.

Avatar

gagay

September 29th, 2005 at 8:02 pm

ano pa etong government lawyer na na-padlock ang office cos he testified about the northrail contract. napaka desperate na talaga ng mga actions ng gobyernong eto, its even worse than watching a low budgetted b-action flick.

Avatar

bornokz

September 29th, 2005 at 8:08 pm

What’s new? That’s the style of ATE GLUE kung alam nyang mabubulgar na naman ang mga baho niya she will do everything to conceal her evil deeds,THE END IS NEAR TO THIS EVIL ADMINISTRATION coz people are now realizing how evil GMA was.Hindi lahat ng oras mag tatanga tangahan lang ang tao,Ngayon pa,that some of the military men are withdrawing their support to this fake president,basta peke hindi magtatagal mabibisto rin at itoy kukupas.Mga pinoy magkaisa na sa pagbabago para sa bayan.

Avatar

Kikay2

September 29th, 2005 at 8:47 pm

What’s with Ate GoLiar and her minions anyway? Looks like they want to do a Martial Law without the benefit of declaring it. First they buy off Congress, then they suppress dissent in our streets with this no rally no permit crap (unconstitutional!) and this calibrated pre-emptive response (translated: bugbugin ang mga rallyists). Now, they wantto gag everyone including the military. Tama na! Sobra Na! Palitan na ang pandak na yan. We deserve better!

Avatar

zorros

September 29th, 2005 at 11:29 pm

EO Evil Order or Executive order ???
Hindi na kailangan i-challenge sa supreme court yan, it is an obvious veiled threat sa mga potential witness against Un-Gloria.

Yabang lagi ni Bunye, kept on saying sa Korte natin pag-usapan yan. He kept on saying it whenever GMAs position is being challenged. Style bulok talaga si GMA and her alalay.

Siguro, hinde na nila kayang hawakan ang senado that is why ate Un-Gloria started using EO as a “Soft Touch” approach.

Avatar

kaffeine

September 30th, 2005 at 4:18 am

gma’s intentions are very obvious for issuing that EO: She wanted to protect herself! bukong-buko na kasi. she should have also been ordered detained by the senate along with her national security adviser.

Avatar

schumey

September 30th, 2005 at 5:15 am

Yung EO means ENTITLED OBSTRUCTION while CPR means CURTAIL RIGHTS OF PEOPLE. These practices only shows us how far the administration will go to cling on to power. Basura na talaga ang gobyernong ito. This EO was issued to protect the rights of the people in the executive branch, but what about the CPR, sila lang ba ang may “rights”? As far as I know, the Bill of Rights is not exclusive to a few but to all.

Avatar

penpenpen88

September 30th, 2005 at 8:31 am

Majority congressmen back the EO. Talagang rubberstamp congress na ito. …obvious ba??? kaya nga kasi tayo umalis sa parliamentary system in the first place kasi yung mga tao sa parliament dati lahat tuta ni marcos… tapos ngayon pilit nilang binabalik ulet yung ganung systema para la na talagang hadlang sa pangungurakot nila sa bansa… shame on you congressmen lackeys of this PP pandak president… your legislative powers are being curtialed na nga palakpak pa kayo ke gloria.. if ganun na wla na naman kayong ginagawa kung di tumungo sa ating pekeng presidente mag resign nalang po kayo.. sayang po yung sinusweldo namin sa inyo..if yes men lang pla kayo..

Avatar

schumey

September 30th, 2005 at 10:43 am

GMA and her spindoctors told the pro-impeachment congressmen to bring the complaints against her to the proper forum and refrain from using media to try her by publicity.

Look who’s using the media now…. The dept. secretaries who were invited to the senate to shed light on the controversial NorthRail project did not attend citing EO 464. These secretaries instead held a presscon and explained this project to newsmen. Why not explain your side in the proper venue. Stop using the media daw, pero pag sila pwede. This administration is full of liars and cheats out to grind our country to the ground.

Palace spindoctors also said that Pres. Aquino had used this EO before…Another lie, it was a Memorandum Order, meaning an internal matter and is only limited to dept. secretaries and has attached guidelines.

GMA is a tyrant by refusing to be transparent. The public deserves to know how the gov’t. spends regardless of how these informations are revealed or acquired. Her continuing blunders has put her on the defensive again.

Once again GMA has painted herself to a corner. She’s running out of options. She may have survived the impeachment in the lowerhouse but the series of hearings in the senate has brought out the allegations she had managed to avoid in congress. I don’t care anymore if these hearings were in aid of legislation or to “fry” GMA, for as long as the truth will come out. Her attackdogs and mouthpieces can bad-mouth the senate for all I care, like I said, “truth comes out even in the weirdest ways”.

Konti na lang at babagsak na si pandak, kaya mga kababayan ko, konting dasal pa…..

Avatar

ole

September 30th, 2005 at 11:31 am

tingnan nyo naman si pandak
kung ngumiti, parang nakangiwi,
muka ni ay si joker na sawi…
hu-hu-hu-hu
kakaawa ka pandak,
buhay ka pa pero amoy patay ka na!
may makipaglamay kaya sa iyo?

Avatar

sensual

September 30th, 2005 at 12:41 pm

How long will it take for the rest of the countrymen to wake up and stop supporting this REGIME?

EO was crafted by no other than 2 secretaries and her legal counsel, and AGAIN, “Raul Gonzales”, the upholder of Law and Justice (supposed) was one of the 3 crafters.

WHEN will this end? 2010? Sure?

Avatar

INSIDE PCIJ: Stories behind our stories » EO 464 unconstitutional — lawyers’ group

September 30th, 2005 at 2:29 pm

[…] THE Counsels for the Defense of Liberties  (CODAL) has branded Executive Order 464, which prohibits senior executive and military officials from appearing before Congress without the president’s permission, as unconstitutional and illegal. […]

Avatar

tikboy

September 30th, 2005 at 2:53 pm

i’ve read a line that goes: The first thing that the devil will do is to convince the world that he does not exist.

apply natin sa presidente niyo: The first thing that the cheater will do is to convice the world that cheating does not exist.

so there she goes, convincing the world that she won fair and square up to the point of bribing the doggies that are now loyally making silip inside her palda for more and more cash. and then the EO 464 which will keep mum the secretaries for fear that they might squel her secrets.

“gloria” does not exist, di ba? impyerno, meron tsaka GLUE-ria.

which reminds me of boy abunda’s political ad for GMA during the 2004 elections na parang kulto ang dating… musta na papa boy a?

Avatar

sinningsaint

September 30th, 2005 at 3:20 pm

zorros said…

“Yabang lagi ni Bunye, kept on saying sa Korte natin pag-usapan yan.”
———————————
asa “payroll” na rin kasi ng executive and judiciary…. EVAT, anyone?

Avatar

xpeller

October 1st, 2005 at 5:50 am

EO 464 is definitely repressive and therefore unconstitutional. Besides, what is there to clear from the office of the president when someone is called by congress to shed light on certain issues? Not unless the president is trying to cover-up something the public should not know.

Avatar

datu_lakandiwa

October 5th, 2005 at 6:57 am

schumey said,
September 30, 2005 @ 10:43 am

…….

Konti na lang at babagsak na si pandak, kaya mga kababayan ko, konting dasal pa…..

_________________________________________________

The PROBLEM is paano kung bagsak at lugmok na sa hirap ang bansa andyan pa rin si ate GLUE????

Avatar

INSIDE PCIJ: Stories behind our stories » Regarding a "state of national emergency" and an extended Congressional recess

October 16th, 2005 at 9:30 pm

[…] Critics have also been talking of an "undeclared martial law" as they point to "draconian measures" that have already been imposed in succession through executive decisions, from the "calibrated preemptive response" (CPR) in dealing with rallies and demonstrations, EO 464 to the Philippine Army’s reported shoot-to-kill orders against recruiters for destabilization. […]

Avatar

INSIDE PCIJ: Stories behind our stories » Apologies and clarifications: The byzantine politics of the U.P. College of Law

November 15th, 2005 at 7:35 pm

[…] On Sept. 28, Alecks Pabico reported in this blog a supposed verbal instruction from the newly appointed U.P. law dean, Salvador Carlota, to members of the U.P. Law Center not to attend the scheduled Senate hearing on the North Rail project in light of President Arroyo’s recently issued Executive Order No. 464. […]

Avatar

INSIDE PCIJ: Stories behind our stories » Panganiban named new chief justice

December 21st, 2005 at 7:15 pm

[…] Colmenares stressed that Panganiban should inhibit himself from all cases involving the President. These cases include the Calibrated Pre-emptive Response Policy and Executive Order 464, which bars government officials from testifying in congressional inquiries without permission from the Palace. […]

Avatar

INSIDE PCIJ: Stories behind our stories » Arroyo legal counsel is new solicitor general

March 18th, 2006 at 1:36 am

[…] As the top government lawyer, Nachura has his hands full with the cases he has inherited from Benipayo, including constitutionality suits against the “calibrated pre-emptive response” policy on street demonstrations, and Executive Order No. 464 prohibiting government and military officials from testifying in congressional inquiries without clearance from Arroyo. […]

Avatar

INSIDE PCIJ: Stories behind our stories » Mayuga report silent on other top military officials linked to poll fraud

April 14th, 2006 at 1:07 pm

[…] A senior officer said that if Executive Order No. 464 will be lifted, a lot of those who might have personal knowledge of what happened might come out and follow the lead of Gudani and Lt. Col. Alexander Balutan. […]

Avatar

oliver_maano

April 16th, 2006 at 11:35 pm

The Mayuga Report… Was it still the real Mayuga Report that they hide to release for sometime… no one knows except the Malacanang… Our countrymen just hope that SC must also release their opinion on the issue of EO464… With that, the Senate must start investigating all the people involve in the Arroyo Administration…

Avatar

INSIDE PCIJ: Stories behind our stories » Supreme Court partially voids EO 464

April 20th, 2006 at 8:49 pm

[…] EO 464, which prohibits senior executive and military officials from appearing in Congress without the president’s permission, was issued by President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo on September 28, 2005. The order was issued as two military officers appeared before the Senate Committee on National Defense which began an investigation on the “Hello, Garci” controversy. It also came a week after National Security Norberto Gonzales testified before the Senate on the equally controversial Venable LLP contract. […]

Avatar

INSIDE PCIJ: Stories behind our stories » Arroyo deliberately cheated her way to the presidency, must vacate post to face charges — Citizens’ Congress

May 10th, 2006 at 11:29 am

[…] the twin acts of cover-up and state repression to counter allegations of crimes committed by Arroyo and challenges to her mandate and legitimacy, citing more summary executions and arrests of political dissenters, the violent dispersal of rallies through the Calibrated Preemptive Response (CPR) rule, the withholding of information from congressional investigations through Executive Order No. 464, and a crackdown on her critics through the imposition of emergency rule under Presidential Proclamation No. 1017. […]

Avatar

INSIDE PCIJ: Stories behind our stories » Senate proposes amendments to rules on inquiries

May 19th, 2006 at 4:59 pm

[…] EO 464 requires Cabinet members, police and military generals, senior national security officials, and “such other officers as may be determined by the President” to seek President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo’s approval before appearing in any inquiry of the Senate or the House of Representatives. […]

Avatar

INSIDE PCIJ: Stories behind our stories » Officers who say no

June 21st, 2006 at 6:09 pm

[…] More recently, there were Brig. Gen. Francisco Gudani (now retired), and Col. Alexander Balutan, both also from the Marines, who defied a presidential order against military officers appearing before congressional inquiries when they testified before the Senate last year on allegations of widespread cheating during the 2004 elections. […]

Avatar

melot

June 22nd, 2006 at 6:51 pm

Hanggang kelan ka di matitinag

Sa kinau-upuan mo, di mo ba naaaninag?

Mga kababayan kong ayaw na sa iyo

Isinisigaw, bumaba ka na sa iyong pwesto

Sa iyong takot, iyong hinakot

Mga aso mong sa iyo ay takot

Na pag di ka sinunod, mawawala sa pwesto

At kung minalas baka mawala dito sa mundo

Mga barikada ay iyong pinalagyan

Sa kalsada at sa harapan ng Malakanyang

Sa takot na ikaw ay lusubin

Ng taong-bayan at ikaw ay patalsikin

Di mo masisisi ang taong-bayan na sila’y magprotesta

Na ang gusto lang naman nila ay muling makalaya

Sa isang dambuhala na katulad mo

Isang mandarayang naka-upo sa pwesto

Kailan ka matitinag, kailan ka bababa?

Sa iyong trono na nakuha sa daya

Pag meron na bang namatay, pag meron ng nagbuwis ng buhay

Ng kababayan nating sandata lamang ay laway

Mga KABABAYAN ating ipaglaban

Ang DEMOKRASYA at KALAYAAN ng ating BAYAN

Sa isang DAMBUHALA na MANDARAYA

Na ayaw bumaba sa pwesto, napaka-kapal ng mukha.

Avatar

kogtong

June 22nd, 2006 at 7:17 pm

GMA is getting unpopular everyday.

Avatar

INSIDE PCIJ » Gov’t asks Supreme Court to reconsider ruling on EO 464

February 1st, 2007 at 11:14 am

[…] EO 464 was issued on September 28, the day Brigadier General Francisco Gudani and Col. Alexander Balutan testified before the Senate on alleged electoral fraud in Mindanao during the 2004 elections. […]

Avatar

The Daily PCIJ » Blog Archive » SC ruling on JPEPA: Shackled by ‘entropy of the old tradition of secrecy’

August 2nd, 2008 at 11:47 am

[…] for having a decent track record in transparency and accountability. (Remember Executive Order Nos. 464, 608 , the fate of the Mayuga and Melo reports, the gag order on NEDA documents, and how Arroyo has […]

Avatar

The Daily PCIJ » Blog Archive » ‘Uncompromised political will’ needed to counter worsening corruption — TI

September 25th, 2008 at 1:17 pm

[…] further added that the attempt to muzzle government executives through Executive Order 464 and the executive privilege are two examples of how the government clamps down on vital information […]

Comment Form